Wellington – All Blacks lock Andy Haden, whose feigned fall from a lineout won New Zealand a match-winning penalty against Wales in 1978 and earned him lasting notoriety, has died. He was 69.
Haden was diagnosed with chronic lymphocytic leukemia in 2003 and his condition, which had been stable, recently worsened. His death at his home on Wednesday was confirmed by a family spokesperson.
While he played 117 in All Blacks matches, including 41 tests — eight as captain — between 1972 and 1985 and is regarded as one of the finest second rowers to have played for New Zealand, Haden became a controversial figure because of his penalty-winning "simulation.”
New Zealand and Wales had been locked in a tight match at Cardiff Arms Park on Nov. 11, 1978; Wales led 12-10 with time running out and its vocal fans sensed Wales’ first win over the All Blacks in 25 years was eminent.
At a late lineout in Welsh territory, rather than competing for the ball, Haden threw himself spectacularly to the ground, accompanying his dive with a loud cry.
The English referee Roger Quittendon penalized Haden’s Welsh marker Alan Martin for a foul. Flyhalf Brian McKechnie, who also played international cricket, claimed a place in New Zealand rugby history when he kicked the goal for a 13-12 win.
Quittendon later said he was not tricked by Haden and had penalized Wales for an offense against Haden’s locking partner Frank Oliver. But Haden remained convinced and unashamed that he had won a penalty with his theatrical performance.
He said he had been obstructed at lineouts throughout the match and decided to have his revenge, telling All Blacks captain Graham Mourie of his plan.
"They climbed over me all day, that’s why we came up with the remedy we did,” he said. "The penalty wasn’t for that, it was for all the other lineouts they had obstructed me all the way through the game and I felt absolutely justified. I also felt you don’t go back to your dressing room asking yourself what more I have done to win the game, don’t be a mug.”
When the All Blacks returned to Wales for that nation’s rugby centenary in 1980, an ornate cake was prepared to mark the occasion, featuring a green field with 15 red players (Wales) and 15 black players (New Zealand). Haden and Oliver tampered with the cake in secret and when it was produced it had two black players (Haden and Oliver) lying on the ground at a lineout.
Haden’s career can’t be defined by the 1978 incident. He was an exceptionally talented, intelligent and resilient lock, among the best in the world in his era.
Haden made his All Blacks debut in 1972 in an unusual match against a New York team at Downing Stadium. He waited five years more for his test debut, which he made at home against the British and Irish Lions. From that point until his retirement he was a key member of the New Zealand team.
He was also ahead of his time, foreseeing rugby’s move to professionalism and often tripping the boundary line between the amateur and professional games.
He was investigated and exonerated by the New Zealand Rugby Union for breaching rugby’s amateur code and went on to become the union’s marketing adviser and one of New Zealand’s first player agents. He also represented New Zealand-born supermodel Rachel Hunter.