WARSAW – A Polish documentary on clergy pedophilia that has shocked the devout country could deal a blow to the chances of the ruling conservatives in this month’s European Parliament elections, given the party’s close ties to the Catholic Church, analysts said Thursday.
With Poland’s two main political forces — the right-wing Law and Justice (PiS) party and the European Coalition, a group of opposition parties led by the liberal Civic Platform (PO) — currently polling neck and neck, the film could effectively swing the outcome of the ballot, observers said.
“This whole affair may tilt the balance in favor of the opposition” in the May 26 EU election, political analyst Stanislaw Mocek said.
He says the PiS, in power since 2015, could pay dearly for its close ties to the Catholic Church, “a symbiosis that has suited both sides,” at least until now.
Posted on YouTube last Saturday, the “Tell No One” film by brothers Tomasz and Marek Sekielski has been viewed more than 17 million times.
The two-hour documentary includes hidden camera footage of victims who are now adults confronting elderly priests about the abuse they suffered decades earlier.
Local media have also been busy publishing witness accounts, commentary and new revelations of child sex abuse by the clergy.
Bishops have come under fire for not responding effectively to cases of abuse, and there have been demands for an independent commission of inquiry to shed light on the issue.
Mocek believes that a shift of 1 or 2 percent of votes away from the PiS because of the pedophilia scandal could prove decisive.
Warsaw-based Catholic theologian Stanislaw Obirek said that both the PiS and the episcopate were “in panic mode.”
He believes next month’s visit by Archbishop Charles Scicluna, a Maltese-based Vatican expert on pedophilia among the priesthood, may result in a series of resignations by Polish bishops.
“Now Archbishop Scicluna is coming and his visit will result in important changes. These won’t be cosmetic changes. Many bishops will leave,” the former Jesuit said.
Scicluna spent 10 years as a Vatican prosecutor investigating cases of pedophilia among the priesthood, making a name for himself with his determination.
Arturo Sosa, the leader of the Roman Catholic Jesuit order the Society of Jesus, said in Warsaw on Wednesday that the root of the church’s problems — both in Poland and abroad — lies in the inordinate power the clergy wields over believers and to a lack of transparency within the institution.
The ruling conservatives appear not to be wasting any time in seeking damage control, having announced plans to raise the prison terms for pedophilia to a maximum 30 years and the age of consent from 15 to 16.
The EU member’s parliament has already examined the bill, which could become law in the next few days as the PiS commands an absolute majority.
But government spokeswoman Joanna Kopcinska rejected as “absurd” suggestions that the bill has anything to do with the EU electoral campaign.
She said the penal code changes have been in the works for more than 10 months.
Still, Deputy Prime Minister Jaroslaw Gowin acknowledged that the public debate over pedophilia “may have certain electoral consequences.”
Influential and controversial priest Tadeusz Rydzyk, the founder of a media empire, denounced what he called a “smear campaign” inspired by “hatred” of the church.
He said that if the purpose of the fight against pedophilia is really the pursuit of good, then “we would also be citing the percentage of people guilty of these crimes in other social groups and showing that the percentage among priests is low.”
Nevertheless, Obirek believes that the church is “on the verge of fundamental change.”