Commentary / Japan

Japan now at a crossroads

Japan faces a snap election on Dec. 14 with Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s “Abenomics” on trial. From the conventional economics perspective of growth measured in gross domestic product, we are told that Japan is “stagnating” with excessive debt.

Economists dispense their usual bromides: “open up the economy”; “join the Trans-Pacific Partnership”; “cut government spending”; “tax more”; “tax less”; “print money” — lurching between austerity and stimulus.

From a futurist’s perspective all this advice is nonsensical. Japan is still undergoing the now global transition of mature industrial economies from short-term material economic growth at whatever social and environmental costs — to a more mature, long-term, system-wide social development.

As other countries in Europe, North America and now China, India and Brazil face the same breakdown of GDP-growth policies, new national scorecards and metrics of company success are emerging.

From the OECD comes the Better Life Index; from Canada, the Canadian Index of Wellbeing; while the European Parliament’s Beyond GDP Conference in 2007 ( led to a proliferation of broader scorecards focused on cash-flow accounting, which even its inventor Simon Kuznets warned was not a measure of national progress.

Citizens in 12 countries polled by Globescan and Ethical Markets approved adding measures for health, education and environment. The United Nations sponsored a debate in 2012 on Bhutan’s Gross National Happiness.

Japan has the opportunity in the election to break away from the past GDP-growth stage. In recent years, all the social and environmental costs are being forced back onto national accounts and company balance sheets. Energy and materials efficiency is the new focus, along with renewable energy, re-manufacturing, recycling and sustainable cities and infrastructure.

Japan’s economy is twice as energy efficient as that of those in North America. “Exergy” studies focus on how much energy in an economy is actually applied to useful work — and how much is wasted through inefficiency. After the 2011 Fukushima nuclear disaster, many see Japan’s solar, wind and geothermal energy as the cleanest, safest way forward, yet — as noted in a recent Economist article — its electric utilities are blocking their access to transmission grids.

Japan pioneered in urban infrastructure, education, robotics, bullet trains, protecting farmlands with huge public investments, raising its ratio of debt to GDP. Yet, conventional economics did not provide an asset side on national GDP — accounting only for this as debt — ignoring the valuable long-term infrastructure assets it created, as well as well-educated, healthy citizens, scientific research, advanced technologies. Furthermore, Japan’s public debt is owned by its citizens — not by foreign bondholders or the sovereign wealth funds of OPEC countries and China.

My advice to Japanese voters and Abe is to change the national scorecard from GDP to a system-wide view of quality of life. Social and environmental costs (the “bads”) must also be subtracted from the goods, while valuing the services and information sectors that now comprise some 70 to 80 percent of mature, post-industrial societies in Japan, Europe and North America. GDP still over-values 19th- and 20th-century material goods while manufacturing has shrunk to less than 20 percent of their output.

Similarly company accounting is modernizing with new standards to account for the six forms of capital which companies can enhance or degrade: financial, manufactured, intellectual, social, human and natural capitals. These new report cards on company performance are promoted by broad coalitions of accounting firms and research groups, including IIRC, SASB, Ceres, Tellus and China’s adoption of the now popular “circular economy” model of the World Economic Forum and Britain’s Ellen MacArthur Foundation.

My advice to Japan: Change from GDP to quality of life; add an asset account to recognize the immense value of public assets, which will slash Japan’s overstated debt-to-GDP ratio — and declare victory over the dead economics of the past.

Recognize and celebrate all of Japan’s true riches in renewable energy, efficiency and intellectual, social and human wealth. Grow Japan’s green sectors and rejoice that capital markets are understanding the transition to the cleaner, greener, inclusive, sustainable societies. Japan’s voters may teach Abe to ditch Abenomics and chart a knowledge-rich, inclusive green economy and future for Japan.

Hazel Henderson is a futurist, evolutionary economist and author of books. The Ethical Markets Media she founded publishes the Green Transition Scoreboard tracking global private-sector investments in green technology.

Coronavirus banner