PARIS – The oceans are poised to unleash misery on a global scale unless the carbon pollution destabilizing Earth’s marine environment is brought to heel, warns a draft U.N. report.
Destructive changes already set in motion — some irreversible — could bring a steady decline in fish stocks, a hundredfold increase in the damage from superstorms, and hundreds of millions of people displaced by rising seas, according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s special report on oceans and Earth’s frozen zones.
Melting glaciers will first give too much water and then too little to the billions who depend on them for fresh water, it finds.
Without deep cuts to man-made emissions, at least 30 percent of the Northern Hemisphere’s surface permafrost could melt by the century’s end, unleashing billions of tons of carbon and accelerating global warming even more.
The 900-page scientific assessment is the fourth from the U.N. in less than a year; the others focused on a cap on global warming of 1.5 degrees Celsius (2.6 degrees Fahrenheit), the state of biodiversity, and how to manage forests and the global food system.
All four conclude that humanity must overhaul the way it produces and consumes almost everything to avoid the worst ravages of climate change and environmental degradation.
Governments will meet in Monaco in September to vet the new report’s official summary. While the underlying science — drawn from thousands of peer-reviewed studies — cannot be modified, diplomats with scientists at their elbow will tussle over how to frame the findings and what to leave in or out.
The final advice to policymakers will be released on Sept. 25, too late to be considered by world leaders gathering two days earlier for a summit convened by U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres to extract stronger national commitments in confronting the climate crisis.
Guterres may be disappointed by what the world’s major greenhouse gas emitters put on the table, according to experts tracking climate politics in China, the United States, the European Union and India.
The Big Four — accounting for nearly 60 percent of fossil fuel-based emissions — all face devastating ocean- and ice-related impacts, but none seems prepared just yet to announce more ambitious goals for purging carbon from their economies.
U.S. President Donald Trump — a no-show at the G7 climate segment this past week — wants the U.S. to exit the Paris agreement and has taken a chain saw to predecessor Barack Obama’s climate policies.
India is rapidly developing solar power but continues to build up coal-fired capacity at the same time.
The European Union is inching toward a midcentury “net zero” emissions goal, but several member states are dragging their feet.
Long seen as a leader on climate, China — which emits nearly as much carbon dioxide as the U.S., EU and India combined — is also sending mixed signals.
“The eyes of Beijing are gradually moving away from environmental issues, and climate change in particular,” noted Greenpeace International analyst Li Shuo, a longtime observer of China’s climate policy.
A resurgence of domestic coal-fired power and a relaxing of air pollution regulations, he said, point to a preoccupation with China’s slowing economy and its trade war with the U.S.
Yet all of these nations face many of the threats outlined in the IPCC report.
Shanghai, Ningbo, Taizhou and another half a dozen major coastal cities in China, for example, are highly vulnerable to higher sea levels, which are projected to rise by a meter by 2100 if emissions continue unabated. Mumbai and other coastal Indian cities are in harm’s way as well.
Even in the United States, where billions are being spent to protect New York, Miami and other exposed cities, such efforts could easily be overwhelmed, say experts.
“There is a pervasive thread in the U.S. right now promoted by techno-optimists who think we can engineer our way out of this problem,” said Michael Mann, director of the Earth System Science Center at Pennsylvania State University. “But the U.S. is not ready for a meter of sea-level rise by 2100. Just look at what happened in the wake of superstorm Sandy, Katrina, in Houston or Puerto Rico.”
By 2050, many low-lying mega-cities and small island nations will experience “extreme sea level events” every year, even under the most optimistic emissions reduction scenarios, the report concludes.
By 2100, “annual flood damages are expected to increase by two to three orders of magnitude,” or 100 to 1,000 times, the draft summary for policymakers says.
Even if the world manages to cap global warming at 2 degrees Celsius, the global ocean waterline will rise enough to displace more than a quarter of a billion people.
The report indicated this could happen as soon as 2100, though some experts think it is more likely to happen on a longer time scale.
“Even if the number is 100 or 50 million by 2100, that’s still a major disruption and a lot of human misery,” said Ben Strauss, CEO and chief scientist of Climate Central, a U.S. based research group.
“When you consider the political instability that has been triggered by relatively small levels of migration today, I shudder to think of the future world when tens of millions of people are moving because the ocean is eating their land.”
Earth’s average surface temperature has gone up 1 degree since the late 19th century and is on track to warm another 2 or 3 degrees by the century’s end.
The Paris agreement calls for capping global warming at “well below” 2 degrees.
Sea level rise will accelerate rapidly moving into the 22nd century and “could exceed rates of several centimeters per year” — about 100 times more than today, according to the report.
“If we warm the planet by 2 degrees, by 2100 we will only be at the beginning of a runaway train ride of sea level rise,” said Strauss, whose research informs the report’s conclusions.
Oceans not only absorb a quarter of the carbon dioxide we emit, they have also soaked up more than 90 percent of the additional heat generated by greenhouse gas emissions since 1970.
Without this marine sponge, global warming would already have made Earth’s surface intolerably hot for our species.
But these obliging gestures come at a cost. Acidification is disrupting the ocean’s basic food chain, and marine heat waves — which have become twice as frequent since the 1980s — are creating vast oxygen-depleted dead zones.
In the Tasman Sea, for example, a 2015-16 heat wave lasted for 251 days, causing disease outbreaks and a die-off of farmed shellfish.