Vatican media praises ‘Spotlight’ as giving voice to victims, says movie not anti-Catholic


The Vatican newspaper praised Oscar-winning film “Spotlight” on Monday as having given voice to the “profound pain” of the faithful over the reality of clerical sex abuse, and insisted it is not an anti-Catholic film.

L’Osservatore Romano dedicated two articles to the Academy Awards and the Best Picture won by “Spotlight,” about the Boston Globe’s 2002 expose of the hundreds of Boston children who were raped and molested by Catholic priests and the church’s systematic cover-up of the crimes.

L’Osservatore quoted producer Michael Sugar’s acceptance speech— “Pope Francis, it’s time to protect the children and restore the faith” — saying even his appeal was positive.

“It means there’s still faith in the institution, there’s faith in a pope who is continuing the cleanup started by his predecessor as cardinal. And there’s still trust in a faith that has at its heart the defense of victims and the protection of innocents,” said the piece by Lucetta Scaraffia, one of L’Osservatore’s main columnists and the editor of its monthly edition on women’s issues.

She said the film is not anti-Catholic “because it manages to give voice to the shock and profound pain of the faithful when confronted with discovery of this horrible reality.”

Vatican Radio, which gave the film an enthusiastically positive review in October when it screened at the Venice Film Festival, also praised “Spotlight” in its Oscar wrap as a “rigorous and authentic” reconstruction, and cited Sugar’s appeal.

The reaction marks a dramatic turnabout by the Vatican from a decade ago and even as recently as 2010, when the last convulsion of the long-running scandal flared as thousands of new victims came forward in Europe, Latin America and beyond. Then, the Vatican paper of record was a vehicle for ringing defenses of how the Holy See had responded and criticism for the “unjust attacks” being hurled against its pope.

Vatican praise for “Spotlight” reflects the generally positive reviews the film has had in Catholic circles: Just a few weeks ago, it was screened in the Vatican for members of Francis’ sex abuse advisory commission. And the Rev. Tim Kesicki, president of the Jesuit Conference in the U.S., said he had recently invited his staff to see it at a Washington theater. He said they left feeling “both moved and devastated.”

“We were moved by the courage of those survivors who came forward and shared their truth, and we were devastated by the size and scope of the suffering,” Kesicki said. “It is a painful story that has to be told.”

The Oscar was handed out just hours after one of the most senior officials in the Vatican, Australian Cardinal George Pell, testified before Australia’s Royal Commission, which is investigating the scope of the abuse scandal there. The public hearing is evidence that more than a decade after the church’s cover-up was exposed, some level of accountability is beginning to take hold.

  • Maria Ashot

    Thank you for this report. Cruelty to children, and especially sexual aggression in all its many hideous manifestations, has to be addressed and eradicated. Children are a precious gift. Even people who have no faith in any divinity recognize that there is something almost miraculous about the arrival of a new human being into our shared world… The person who believes it is acceptable to torment and exploit a child is a sociopath, a pathological phenomenon in the human community, and certainly not anyone who can be allowed to act on these convictions. The rapist priests are one example. Without a doubt, Catholicism’s insistence on “celibate clergy” (after many centuries of having married clergy and even married bishops — the norm in early Christian communities) has been a contributor to the selection of men with perverse sexual appetites for ordination. But extreme cruelty against children takes many forms: consider the case yesterday of a “nanny” in Moscow beheading someone’s young daughter! As obvious as it may seem to many of us already numb from reading the daily news and abuse reports, it is imperative that decent people everywhere speak up emphatically in denunciation of all those who cause grievous harm to children, and insist on actions being taken — by the Vatican, but also by civil authorities — to fight back against the tide of smug superiority & arrogance that seems to be the hallmark of every child tormentor or child rapist.