Simulated patients pitch Japan’s medical students cultural curve balls


Charlotte Marshall, an elderly American living in Tokyo, isn’t happy. Accompanied by her daughter, Rebecca Peterson, she is visiting a local clinic.

Charlotte has been experiencing some “senior moments” of late and Rebecca is concerned. Things go well at first, but when the young Japanese doctor, struggling to conduct the consultation in English, continually addresses his questions about Charlotte’s condition to Rebecca, her mother finally reprimands him: “Don’t ignore me! Talk to me, not about me.” Chastened, the doctor hastily apologizes and endeavors to include both women in the ensuing conversation.

In real life, “Charlotte” is Ann Endo, a retired nurse who has raised her family in Japan, while “Rebecca” is Christine Benson, a U.S.-registered nurse currently based in Tokyo because of her spouse’s work. The doctor is actually a student at The Jikei University in Tokyo. All three are taking part in an innovative program called Simulated Patients (SP for short), which matches foreign volunteer patients with Japanese medical students for role-play.

It is a rare opportunity for the students to hone both their language skills and bedside manner in English. The volunteer patients, who undergo training before entering the program, are assigned identities and a case history for each session, and then attempt to stay in character while interacting as naturally as possible with the “doctor” during each role-play.

The Japanese health care system is frequently praised for offering universal coverage and freedom of choice when it comes to providers. However, while appreciating such qualities, foreign nationals sometimes cite problems such as consultations being too rushed, doctors diagnosing them after scarcely any questioning and medication being dispensed without adequate explanation. Undoubtedly some of these problems lie with the way the medical insurance system is set up, but cross-cultural understanding could also go a long way in allaying patient anxieties.

Ruri Ashida, a university professor, initiated SP and continues to spearhead the program.

“Along with foreign nationals coming to Japan long-term for work or marriage, we have seen a recent growth in the number of overseas tourists in Japan. And with the 2020 Olympics scheduled for Tokyo, now is a very good time for the medical profession to gain a better understanding of the needs of non-Japanese patients,” she notes.

The program with the first trained SPs was test-piloted in 2012 in classes at Ashida’s former workplace, Tokyo Medical University, and then in mid-2013 she introduced the program to her students at the University of Tokyo, where she is still teaching.

In the fall of 2013, Ashida joined forces with Christine Kuramoto, an English teacher at Hamamatsu University School of Medicine in Shizuoka Prefecture. As there were no SPs in Hamamatsu at the time, Ashida took three volunteers from Tokyo with her. Sessions have since been conducted at several locations around Japan, including in Okayama, Akita and Tokushima prefectures.

This latest session took place at The Jikei University in downtown Tokyo. The director of the university’s Center for International Affairs, Dr. Kunihiko Fukuda, invited Ashida to set up an expanded program on-site after attending one of her workshops in Akita and being impressed with the potential benefits.

Currently, medical students may choose to participate in the SP program as part of their electives program.

“This is a very valuable opportunity for our students, and eventually I’d like to see it included in the main curriculum, as well as offering similar opportunities to all our staff, including nurses and receptionists,” says Fukuda.

Along with the chance to practice her English, one fifth-year medical student at Jikei, who asked not to be named, credits SP with opening her eyes to various cultural nuances, which she hopes to draw on when she travels to the United Kingdom and Germany this spring on overseas training.

“After conducting a number of consultations with the volunteers, we can go back and watch the videotapes of ourselves,” she said. “There were various things to consider — for example, the heights of the chairs in the consultation room. Japanese doctors are usually seated on a chair and the patients sit on a low stool, which makes the doctor seem like an authoritarian figure. I realized that Western patients are used to thinking of the doctor as an equal — even a family friend if they have been regular patients for many years.”

Another student said she was surprised at how much her foreign patients talked during the session. “They asked a lot of questions and liked to chat, so I was worried about running out of time and I had to try and steer the conversation back to the issue at hand,” she said.

Fukuda notes that even when students are comfortable using English, there can be marked differences between daily conversation and speaking in a professional setting.

“One student was flummoxed when a volunteer patient used the word ‘waterworks,’ a polite British euphemism for the urinary system. However, when the student later tried to use the same term with another patient, the person had no idea what he was talking about,” Fukuda shares with a grin.

While there is growing interest among the medical community in implementing SP sessions, it has taken a great deal of time and nurturing to get the program this far. Having a ready pool of foreign patients for the program is essential.

Volunteers are asked to commit for at least a year, but the longer the better as far as the facilitators are concerned. They are paid a token amount for their efforts, as well as expenses if they travel for a session, but the main incentive for volunteers is a desire to contribute to making visits to the doctor that little bit more comfortable for other foreign nationals. There are currently round 30 regular volunteers, including Australian, New Zealand, Chinese, Indian, Dutch and German nationals.

Endo — who, based on her very realistic portrayal of Charlotte, may have missed her calling as an actress — has been with the program since the outset and has brought a number of other volunteers on board through her involvement with the Foreign Nurses Association of Japan and the Association of Foreign Wives of Japanese.

“I believe in the mission!” she says. “It’s small steps towards a big goal, but you have to start somewhere. I’m thrilled that the program is up and running.”

For Briton Tim Harris, the role-playing should be second nature. The guest lecturer and actor was recruited after Ashida watched him on stage in a Tokyo International Players production.

“It sounded worthwhile and interesting and so I signed on. It’s a way to give back to the community,” Harris says.

Ashida would dearly love to see the SP program expand throughout Japan.

“However, we are still quite some way off that goal, realistically,” she admits. “We need foreign nationals willing to train and commit to the program, along with support staff to write the scenarios for the volunteer patients and to coordinate the sessions. I can help to train people to set up programs in other hospitals, but then ideally they would be autonomous.”

Ashida is grateful that her work to date has been generously supported by university funds and government research grants, but she can’t predict how long the funding might be available.

Relaxing at the end of the session, Benson is satisfied with her efforts.

“This was the first time I worked with another volunteer SP, and I enjoyed it,” she says. “It was actually easier than usual, because I could play off what Ann was saying.”

When Benson expresses an interest in more family role-playing during future sessions, mother-of-three Endo smiles. “How about a pregnant foreign woman and her Japanese husband attending a prenatal clinic visit?” she says. “There is plenty of potential there.”

Ashida adopts a thoughtful expression and nods. “Yes, that could be something to build on. We have many things still to try.”

The Simulated Patients program is seeking English-speaking foreign volunteers. For further details, see www.sp-english.org or contact Ruri Ashida at japanengsp@gmail.com. Your comments and story ideas: community@japantimes.co.jp

  • Rhonda Culver Tezuka

    The SP program is a very rewarding program for the doctors, nurses and the volunteers. It truly gives the students a chance to challenge their training in a realistic situation . I strongly encourage foreigners to volunteer for this program!
    Rhonda T.

  • Hans Gruber

    Good article.

    The Modern Western doctor/patient relationship is on equal terms. Patients are encouraged to ask questions, understand their condition, and even question the doctor if they are unsure or uncomfortable with the doctor’s diagnosis or treatment.

    Japan has some very good doctors across all age groups but there is an unfortunate authoritarian streak in others. This sits fine with some older Japanese patients, but bristles others.

    The problem is that authoritarian doctors take even polite questions as a challenge to their authority and respond with no explanation but a ‘just do as i say!’ angry rebuke.

    Another thing is over-prescribing antibiotics which is common in Japan but frowned on in the West because it has caused strains of antibiotic-resistant bacteria like golden staph and MRSE.

    Problem is sometimes you really do need antibiotics but what is the patient supposed to do if politely asking ‘do i really need this’ the doctor only earns them an angry rebuke? Doctors are human too and do make occasional mistakes. Patients can help doctors catch these early on but only if the doctors respectfully listen to and answer their questions. That is how a relationship of equals helps.

    Exposing the SP trainees to inquisitive Western patients will help them be better doctors to Japanese patients too.

    • KenjiAd

      … Exposing the SP trainees to inquisitive Western patients will help them be better doctors to Japanese patients too.

      Perhaps. I think it depends on how well the mock patients act.

      Although patient-doctor relationship is supposedly on equal terms, but in reality, it isn’t. The reasons are two fold; (1) the patients know doctors have more knowledge and skills, and (2) patients are suffering and they usually want a remedy immediately. This latter point is obviously not shared by mock patients.

      Good doctors are aware that these inherent power imbalance could prevent them from establishing a good rapport with patients. Many patients get easily frustrated and not trusting their doctors. The problem exasperates because nowadays most patients and their families come to a clinic with the information they have gathered on the Internet (many of which are wrong), potentially pushing doctors to a defensive mode.