SYDNEY/SINGAPORE – The sheer volume of flights in the skies over Southeast Asia is putting pressure on outdated air traffic control and on pilots to take risky unilateral action in crises such as that possibly faced by AirAsia Flight QZ8501.
Pilots who have flown the route from Indonesia to Singapore say that it is not unusual to experience delays in getting approval for requests to increase altitude to avoid bad weather, and that some requests are eventually rejected due to the number of other planes in the area.
That leaves pilots flying in a region of volatile weather conditions facing a high-risk challenge: deciding whether to take matters into their own hands and declare an emergency, allowing them to take action without getting permission from air traffic control.
Most consider that step — which requires them to broadcast a wide-band call to other aircraft in the area and which will later be closely scrutinized by regulators — a last resort.
“As a professional pilot, you are obligated to think quickly,” said a Qantas Airways pilot with 25 years experience in the region. “If you’ve signed for the plane, as we put it, you’ve signed for potentially 300 passengers and millions of dollars worth of aircraft. That’s a multibillion-dollar liability. Part of the job is to balance the risk and make a snap decision.”
Weighing those risks has become increasingly difficult in Southeast Asia, an area that has seen explosive growth in budget air travel in recent years.
The number of passengers carried annually across the Asia-Pacific region has jumped by two-thirds in the past five years to more than 1 billion, according to the Centre for Asia Pacific Aviation, based in Sydney. Budget airlines, which only took to the skies around a dozen years ago, today make up about 60 percent of Southeast Asia’s seat capacity. AirAsia and Indonesia’s Lion Air have placed record orders with the main plane makers.
Boeing predicts the region’s airlines will need about 13,000 new planes over the next two decades, and Airbus expects Asia-Pacific to drive demand over that period.
Logistical nightmare
“There are certain flight corridors that are overstressed due to traffic,” said a former Singapore Airlines (SIA) pilot with a decade’s flying experience at the carrier. “One certainly would be the Indonesia/Singapore flights, which are flown by many different companies and aircraft types at a variety of altitudes and speeds.”
Pilots say that causes a logistical nightmare for the region’s air traffic control (ATC), particularly outside high-tech hubs such as Singapore.
“As the airways become more crowded, it takes ATC longer to coordinate and give clearances such as higher altitudes and weather deviations,” the former SIA pilot said.
This can be critical in a region where weather conditions can change very quickly, with strong winds and tropical thunderstorms posing time-critical challenges for pilots.
The circumstances around the AirAsia crash are not yet known, but investigators and the airline’s chief, Tony Fernandes, have pointed to changeable weather being a significant factor.
The Association of Asia Pacific Airlines said last month that while airlines were investing heavily in fuel-efficient planes to meet rising demand, there was growing concern about the need to also invest in related infrastructure, such as airport terminals, runways and air navigation services.
Outdated equipment
To keep aircraft traveling in a flight corridor at a safe distance from each other, air traffic controllers in Indonesia employ procedural separation, in which they use pilots’ radio reports to calculate their position relative to other traffic.
That takes longer than the more sophisticated radar separation used in Singapore and elsewhere in the world, which allows a controller to more quickly take stock of radar returns from all aircraft in the area.
A lack of up-to-date equipment and volatile weather conditions were cited by pilots and aviation experts in the 2013 crash of a Lion Air Boeing 737, when the pilot reported the plane being “dragged down” by wind into the sea just short of the runway.
That was considered a classic example of wind shear — the sudden change in wind speed and direction. Airports in the region’s popular island resorts, including Bali, Koh Samui, Langkawi and Cebu, don’t have on-ground wind shear detection equipment to help pilots land and take off.
Pilots said critical decisions often come down to experience.
“In my opinion, if I don’t get permission (to change course) and there’s weather ahead, I’ll just deviate and deal with the authorities later,” said another former SIA pilot who is now with a Persian Gulf carrier.
In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.