KANAZAWA, Ishikawa Pref. – Plaintiffs made their closing arguments Wednesday in an appeal before the Nagoya High Court seeking the permanent shutdown of the Monju fast-breeder nuclear reactor prototype, which has stood idle since a massive sodium coolant leak in December 1995.
The plaintiffs, residents of Tsuruga, Fukui Prefecture, are requesting that the Kanazawa branch of the high court overturn a Fukui District Court decision that in March 2000 rejected their suit seeking to annul the government’s permission to build the plant and a court order to scrap the project.
Construction of the plant began in October 1985 in the town on the Sea of Japan coast. The reactor was operating at 40 percent of capacity when the leak occurred and sparked a fire. The governmental operator of the plant tried to cover up the accident and submitted a falsified report.
The high court is expected to examine whether a risk assessment, conducted by the governmental Nuclear Safety Commission before the construction, was adequate, and it will assess the risks of future sodium leaks and heat-exchanger ruptures.
The lower court claimed the reactor does not pose “any visible danger to . . . the lives or health of the plaintiffs” despite the accident. The suit was initially filed with the district court in September 1985.
In the appeal, the plaintiffs said the lower court declared the reactor safe based on the basic design of conventional light-water reactors powered by uranium. They said the light-water type is very different from fast-breeder reactors, which use plutonium-uranium mixed-oxide fuel.
They claimed almost no safety assessments were done based on fast-breeder reactors and alleged the ruling wrongly concluded that the reactor would be safe, based on testimony by the defendants.
Monju is classified by the government as a prototype for a planned series of reactors.
Fast-breeder reactors produce more plutonium than they consume. Plutonium is an extremely toxic substance that can be used to make nuclear weapons.
A number of countries, including Britain, Germany, France and the United States, have scrapped projects for fast-breeder reactors.
In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.