Beijing – Cherry Lin wistfully strokes a one-piece baby outfit, fretting it may be too small for a son she is yet to meet — one of hundreds of Chinese mothers estranged from babies born to commercial surrogates overseas after the novel coronavirus forced border closures.
China banned all forms of surrogacy — both commercial and altruistic — in 2001 due to concerns poor women were being exploited.
But for $35,000 to $75,000, couples can seek women abroad, from Laos and Russia, to Ukraine, Georgia and the U.S., to carry their babies.
The system has been tipped into chaos by the pandemic, which has seen borders closed, flights canceled and visas pulled, creating a backlog of newborns waiting to be picked up by their biological Chinese parents.
It has also revived the black market for surrogacy inside China.
“Baby dens” with dozens of newborns in orphanages or apartments have been found as the situation worsens, according to surrogacy agencies in Russia and Ukraine.
“I can’t sleep at night thinking my baby is stuck in an orphanage,” says Lin, who opted for surrogacy after suffering several miscarriages, from the southern city of Chengdu.
Her baby was born in St. Petersburg in June, three months after Russia closed it’s border with China to curb the spread of the novel coronavirus.
“We don’t know how long we have to wait,” she concedes.
Rising incomes, high rates of infertility and the desires of old couples — well past their reproductive age — to have a son after China scrapped its one-child rule in 2016 has fueled the demand for foreign surrogates.
Lin, a 38-year-old lawyer, and her husband traveled to Russia last year for IVF and to sign a contract with a surrogacy company.
Once the pregnancy was confirmed she shopped for baby products, and even took an infant first aid course.
But her plans unraveled as the virus swept the globe, dropping her into “a nightmare”, where she receives fragments of her newborn’s first weeks through photos and video clips sent by the surrogacy agency.
Losing precious time
China’s foreign ministry and the Russian embassy in Beijing did not respond to queries from AFP about what they were doing to help Chinese parents bring their babies home.
And there are no official figures on how many Chinese babies born to surrogates are stranded abroad.
But a video posted in June by surrogacy service BioTexCom in Ukraine, showing rows of babies in cribs in a hotel, pointed to the scale of the crisis.
Nearly half of the 46 babies belonged to Chinese clients, a BioTexCom spokesperson said.
Authorities have since issued special permits for biological parents to claim their children despite border closures.
But that is not enough for Li Mingxia, whose son was born in May in Kiev.
Quarantine requirements and infrequent flights means she is still unlikely to reach him until late November.
“I will miss the first six months of his life,” Li explains, adding, “I can’t get that back.”
Most babies born abroad do not have birth certificates since their parents are unable to travel to take the DNA tests needed to prove parentage.
Russian and Ukranian police have also started raiding the baby dens — apartments where five or six undocumented babies are being looked after by one nanny — amid fears of human trafficking, Russian state media reported.
“When the police find several Chinese babies without any identification papers, living in a house with a stranger, it looks like you are selling babies for organ harvesting,” according to Dmitriy Sitzko, China marketing manager for Vera Surrogacy Center in St. Petersburg, who worked with Lin.
Lin’s agency found a spot at a state-run orphanage to care for her baby for free. But some agencies in Russia charge parents anywhere between 7,000 to 21,000 yuan ($1,000 to $3,000) per month, Sitzko said.
Celebrities normalize surrogacy
Nearly 1 in 4 couples of reproductive age in China have suffered from infertility, according to the Global Burden of Disease study published in medical journal The Lancet in 2017.
Some studies have linked high levels pollution to declining male fertility, while women are choosing to delay motherhood due to the high costs of living, restrictive maternity policies and high childcare costs.
Surrogacy is sometimes chosen when fertility treatments, such as IVF, don’t work for the couple or if they are unable to carry a child.
Stars such as Elton John, Cristiano Ronaldo, Nicole Kidman and Kim Kardashian West have said they’ve used surrogates to expand their families, raising the profile of the practice — but it remains controversial.
The U.N. has warned commercial surrogacy risked turning children into “commodities” and called for better regulation in places where it is legal.
“There is no right to have a child under international law. Children are not goods or services that the State can guarantee or provide. They are human beings with rights,” Maud de Boer-Buquicchio, Special Rapporteur on the sale and sexual exploitation of children, wrote in a 2018 report.
Only a handful of countries allow international surrogacy.
AFP interviews with 15 surrogacy service providers found it costs about $35,000 to $50,000 for surrogacy in Ukraine and Georgia, $73,000 in Russia and $200,000 in California, one of the few U.S. states where it is legal.
Russia and former soviet countries including Ukraine, Georgia and Belarus are the top destinations for Chinese couples looking for a birth mother.
The sector was displaced from Asia, with Laos the only remaining nation to allow international surrogacy after Thailand and India — long time hot spots — banned it.
Black market babies
Even in Russia and Ukraine a backlash against foreign surrogacy is building, with politicians and activists warning that women and children are being exploited by wealthy foreigners.
But as global travel restrictions have brought the industry to a halt, people are instead turning to the local black market.
Shenzhou Zhongtai, an agency in the southern city of Gaungzhou, told AFP that it costs 600,000 yuan ($87,000) for “successful transplanting and delivery.”
“Add another 200,000 yuan (about $30,000) for sex selection, and another 200,000 yuan for Dragon and Phoenix twins,” an agent said — referring to a package that allowed couples to have a boy and a girl.
Army officers, communist party cardre or judges who can’t travel abroad because of their sensitive jobs are the main clients for China’s underground surrogacy agencies that go unpunished because of their official connections.
“If there is any legal problems, we can fix it,” said Ye Danni, an agent for Laos Baby International Reproductive Clinic that had to pause their operations abroad due to travel restrictions.
Lin, who gave up her law practice to have a baby, says she was too afraid to turn to the Chinese black market — but the pandemic has made her rue that choice.
“If I’d taken that risk,” she says, “I’d be holding my baby today.”
In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.
Your news needs your support
Since the early stages of the COVID-19 crisis, The Japan Times has been providing free access to crucial news on the impact of the novel coronavirus as well as practical information about how to cope with the pandemic. Please consider subscribing today so we can continue offering you up-to-date, in-depth news about Japan.