Business / Economy

BOJ-watchers pare back expectations of future policy changes

by Yuko Takeo


Economists now see a lower chance of any further changes to Bank of Japan monetary policy through the 2019 calendar year, after the central bank last week announced the most significant changes in two years.

The 42 respondents to a survey were unanimous in predicting no additional action this year. More than half — 57 percent — said they expect it only after 2019 — up from 41 percent in the poll prior to the July meeting.

The latest poll was conducted from Friday through Monday.

A sales tax hike scheduled to take place in October 2019 will probably prevent the BOJ from risking an outright hike in the target for 10-year bond yields, said Shigeto Nagai, head of Japan economics at Oxford Economics in Tokyo.

“Until they confirm at least some of the effects of the sales tax hike, I don’t think the BOJ can move their 0 percent target,” Nagai said.

The BOJ kept that yield target nominally unchanged on July 31, while saying it would let the yield move in a slightly wider range. It also cut the amount of commercial bank reserves subject to its negative interest rate and introduced forward guidance, saying it would keep interest rates extremely low for “an extended period of time.”

Economists disagreed about whether the changes amounted to a small step toward normalization. The BOJ said they were meant to increase sustainability as it struggled to reach its 2 percent inflation target — a goal that is increasingly seen as out of reach.

“I do have a baseline view that the 2 percent target is becoming an illusion, a mirage,” said Nagai, adding that 1 percent is likely the norm for the country over the long term.

The BOJ cut its inflation forecasts for coming years and now sees core consumer prices rising 1.6 percent in the fiscal year ending March 2021. Gov. Haruhiko Kuroda said momentum toward 2 percent remains in place, but hasn’t said exactly when he expects to hit it.

Nearly three-quarters of economists surveyed said they don’t expect that target to be reached until after the 2022 calendar year.

BOJ board members did the best they could to address policy side effects without excessively roiling markets, according to Mari Iwashita, chief market economist at Daiwa Securities Co.

“As proof that they handled it well, we saw neither extreme yen strengthening nor stock declines,” Iwashita said. “In that sense their method was perfect. That said, the market view on what the BOJ actually did has been split following the meeting, and we’ve seen a generally uneasy market for the past week.”

“In our view, the BOJ’s next move is likely to be an incremental boost to its yield-curve targets,” said economist Yuki Masujima. “But this is unlikely to happen by the end of this year, given the introduction of forward guidance to maintain the current extremely low yields for an extended period.”

The BOJ said it will continue looking closely at policy side effects, including the impact on profits at commercial banks.

“The BOJ and the banks are both in a long, drawn-out battle,” said Nana Otsuki, chief analyst at Monex Inc. in Tokyo. “From the banks’ perspective, policy sustainability isn’t at a level where the BOJ can keep going as is for years.”

Otsuki said she expected the BOJ to maintain its current policy framework for some time, but said the BOJ could take further steps to mitigate the effects on banks.

One option would be an even wider range for 10-year JGB yields, or it could shift its focus to targeting 5-year yields instead, Otsuki said.