Ukraine crisis has Japan on horns of a dilemma

Stance against territory violations endangers closer ties with Russia


Staff Writer

As the crisis in Ukraine drags on, Japan faces the difficult task of striking a delicate balance between standing by the United States, its main military ally, and maintaining a good relationship with resource-rich Russia.

Observers say Japan must take a clearer stance against any violations of territorial sovereignty while at the same time continue to show Russia that it hopes to build a close relationship. Any signs of wavering on the issue could have a negative impact on ongoing territorial disputes, including over the Senkaku Islands in the East China Sea, they said.

Japan imposed visa bans on 23 people Tuesday, as it followed the United States and European Union in announcing expanded sanctions against Russia over its actions in Ukraine.

“This is a difficult diplomatic issue. But Japan needs to send a clear signal (to the international community) that it will not approve of a violation of Ukraine’s territorial sovereignty,” said Shigeki Hakamada, a professor of Russian affairs at Niigata University.

“Japan has a dilemma,” he added: It not only wants to act in sync with the U.S. — it also wants to build good relations with Russia when ties with other neighboring countries such as China and South Korea have been strained.

“Japan is right in trying to build close ties with Moscow as its long-term policy. But it needs to take a clear stance over an individual issue,” Hakamada said. “After all, Japan is the only country among the Group of Seven major industrialized nations that can truly understand the pain of Ukraine because its territorial integrity has been violated by Russia.”

The Foreign Ministry said Tuesday that the Russian nationals on its sanctions list — whom it did not identify but who were reported by media to include government officials — were suspected of violating “Ukraine’s sovereignty and territory.”

Moscow vowed Tuesday to retaliate over the visa ban, with Russia’s Foreign Ministry saying that the decision was “met with disappointment in Moscow” and would “not be left without a response.”

“Attempts by Japan to put pressure on Russia will in no way help de-escalate tensions around Ukraine,” the statement added.

Observers, however, said that the visa bans will do no real damage to Russia, as most of the officials have no interest in visiting Japan anyway.

“The visa bans are only symbolic sanctions. They will do no substantial damage to Moscow,” Hakamada said, adding that Russia could impose sanctions on Japan, but these, too, would be symbolic.

In an interview with Russia’s Tass news agency, former Ambassador to Japan Alexander Panov also said that Tokyo’s sanctions appeared more symbolic and moderate than U.S. and EU moves, adding that they are aimed at maintaining strategic relations, political dialogue and economic cooperation with Russia.

While assessing Russia’s countermeasures against Japan’s new sanctions, Hakamada said that Tokyo needs to decide other ways to send a clearer message to Moscow.

Meanwhile, Putin’s expected visit to Tokyo this fall could be canceled after Foreign Minister Fumio Kishida postponed a planned trip to Moscow in April — a move apparently taken to avoid damaging the Japan-U.S. alliance ahead of U.S. President Barack Obama’s Tokyo visit last month, experts said.

Kishida was expected to discuss with his counterpart in Moscow details of Putin’s visit to Tokyo, which Japan saw as a chance to bolster economic ties and restart discussions on stalled territorial disputes over four Russian-held and Japan-claimed islands off Hokkaido.

Putin, however, has no plans to compromise on those territorial disputes, regardless of Japan’s stance on Ukraine, Hakamada said.

Relations between Moscow and Tokyo have been strained for decades because of the status of the four islands. The territorial dispute has hurt the two nations’ trade relations and prevented the signing of a peace treaty formally ending World War II hostilities.

Information from AFP-JIJI, JIJI added

  • sangos

    I feel sorry for japan…. where once the spirit of the Samurai defined this nation.

  • PoPfiction.com

    The real issue for Japan has to be the present and ever growing threat of China. China’s activity in the Ukraine is the direct cause of the current unrest. China has seized 10% of the farms in Ukraine displacing the native population. Ukraine was also China’s number one source of weapons and food. China’s aircraft carrier now menacing the people of Japan was purchased from the Ukraine’s disposed tyrant.

    PM Abe offered Putin his hand of friendship to help free Eastern Europe from the ever growing Chinese cancer. Sadly, Putin choose surrender to China over Japan’s friendship. First Putin surrendered Siberia. Now he is surrendering Crimea to Chinese domination and colonization.

    America’s foreign policy is short sighted at best. America has followed European colonialists and imperialist into one disastrous defeat after another and is subject to tragic misjudgements such as its unfortunate misunderstandings with Japan in the 1920’s. Nevertheless, Americans are Japan’s true and loyal friends. Japan must accept a leadership role in liberating both Ukraine and Russia from Chinese domination. PM Abe should offer full support to the Nationalists of both Ukraine and Russia.

  • C321

    Japan needs to be tough on this one. The Russian people we understand and respect such toughness. Russia can’t afford to cut of all its customers for raw materials.

  • Hakamada: “Japan is the only country among the Group of Seven major industrialized nations that can truly understand the pain of Ukraine because its territorial integrity has been violated by Russia”.
    Oh please…My mother threw away my rock collection when I was 12yo. The pain is well-known to everyone. Lame. Japan really has no need for Russian/Mongolian resources….though China does, and yet it is playing its hand with great skill.