BERLIN – Senior German officials are planning a last-ditch drive to convince the government to consider excluding Chinese firms such as Huawei from building Germany’s 5G infrastructure, concerned that it could compromise national security.
The behind-the-scenes push in Berlin, which comes after decisions by Australia and the United States to ban Chinese suppliers from 5G, has emerged at a late stage, with Germany expected to start its 5G auctions in early 2019.
Because of this momentum, officials said it was unclear whether the initiative would succeed.
The push highlights the extent of the concern in some Berlin ministries about a Chinese role in building Germany’s next-generation mobile network, despite the lack of a vigorous public debate about the security dimensions of 5G.
“There is serious concern. If it were up to me, we would do what the Australians are doing,” said one senior German official involved in the internal 5G debate.
Leading the charge are officials in the foreign and interior ministries, who have held talks with their U.S. and Australian counterparts and share their concerns about the risks of using Chinese suppliers like Huawei, the world’s largest telecommunications equipment manufacturer.
They are pressing for a more serious discussion on 5G before the auction process begins, the senior official said. Some officials suggested this could lead to a delay.
Opposition parties are also pushing back. Last week the Greens submitted a motion in parliament that questioned the government stance that it has no legal basis for excluding certain suppliers from its 5G rollout.
“Excluding all investors from a certain country is the wrong approach,” said Katharina Droege, a Greens lawmaker who co-authored the Bundestag motion. “But we need to be able to vet individual cases in order to ensure our critical infrastructure is protected. That could lead to the exclusion of Chinese firms from building our 5G infrastructure.”
So far the public debate over 5G has centered around how extensive next-generation mobile network coverage will be. Current coverage is patchy; that, combined with delays in building high-speed internet services, has been criticized by business groups as a handicap in the digital era.
The security concerns center around China’s National Intelligence Law, approved in 2017, which states that Chinese “organizations and citizens shall, in accordance with the law, support, cooperate with and collaborate in national intelligence work.”
This has sparked fears that Huawei could be asked by the Chinese government to incorporate “back doors” into their equipment that would allow Beijing access for spying or sabotage.
Some experts also see a risk that Chinese intelligence may develop an ability to subvert Huawei’s equipment.
A Huawei spokesman rejected any suggestion that it might pose a threat to national security: “Cybersecurity has always been our top priority, and we have a proven track record of providing secure products and solutions for our customers in Germany and around the world.”
Huawei has called Australia’s decision in August to ban it from 5G “politically motivated” and based on a “mistaken and narrow understanding” of Chinese law. It has stressed that it is a private company with no formal links to the government.
Last week, after The Australian newspaper published a story saying Huawei staffers had been used by Chinese intelligence to obtain access codes to infiltrate a foreign network, the company denied that it had ever “provided or been asked to provide customer information for any government or organization.”
Huawei has been a partner of Deutsche Telekom and other carriers in Germany for years, establishing a sizable presence in the German market.
In recent months, a flurry of German politicians — from the national as well as state and local governments — have visited its headquarters in Shenzhen as part of the company’s ambitious lobbying efforts.
“Following Australia’s decision to exclude the Chinese from their 5G network, there is huge angst at Huawei,” said a senior industry official. “They fear a domino effect. If it stops with Australia, it is not such a big deal. But if it continues, it’s serious. A 5G setback in Germany could ripple across Europe.”
The debate in Germany comes at a time of growing concern about Chinese investments and influence in Europe. Berlin is in the process of tightening its foreign takeover rules to prevent Chinese rivals from snapping up German tech companies.
The European Commission, meanwhile, has kicked off a debate about strategic autonomy, arguing that Europe must ensure that it does not become overly reliant on the United States or China in the digital age.
But excluding Huawei and other Chinese firms is no simple task. Huawei is a global leader in 5G, and its technology is among the most advanced and cheapest. European alternatives include Ericsson and Nokia.
“If the conclusion of your strategic autonomy debate is that you as a state must have control over everything, then it’s going to cost a lot of money,” said Paul Timmers, a research fellow at Oxford University and former director of cybersecurity at the European Commission’s digital directorate. “You have to think about whether it’s realistic and whether you can afford it.”
Some officials in Berlin, Washington and Canberra also expressed concerns about whether Germany’s fragile coalition government is strong and forward-thinking enough to take a big decision like banning Chinese firms from 5G — a step that could have major consequences for Germany’s relations with China.
“I do worry about this. It may be too late,” a second senior German official said, acknowledging that business interests, rather than strategic factors, have driven German policy on such issues for decades.