WASHINGTON – The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) is investigating the discovery of genetically engineered wheat in an Oregon field as the outcry mounted Friday among consumer groups and after Japan suspended some American imports.
U.S. regulators said the wheat carries no risks but the outcome of the probe — namely finding out whether such wheat is growing elsewhere — could have a wider impact on world markets, experts said.
“No one wants genetically engineered wheat,” said Bill Freese, science policy analyst at the Center for Food Safety, recalling that massive opposition in 2004 led seed giant Monsanto to pull back from its bid to commercialize it.
GE wheat is not approved for commercial sale anywhere in the world, but some herbicide-resistant plants were found in April on an Oregon farm, triggering a government investigation, officials announced Wednesday.
Market jitters ensued as Japan canceled a bid for 25,000 tons of U.S. wheat and the European Union told its member states to test imports from the area, saying any genetically modified wheat would not be sold to consumers.
Taiwan’s Flour Millers Association said imports from the United States were under review, and South Korean millers also temporarily suspended purchases of soft white wheat from the United States. Both groups urged nations not to overreact.
The altered wheat is glyphosate-resistant, which means it contains a transgene that allows it to survive when a popular weedkiller made by Monsanto, called Roundup, is sprayed on fields.
The GE wheat was tested at more than 100 sites in the United States from 1998 to 2005, but the last approved field trials in Oregon were in 2001, according to the USDA’s Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service.
Monsanto said it is cooperating with the probe and vowed to “conduct a rigorous investigation to validate the scope of and to address any presence of a Monsanto Roundup Ready event in commercial wheat seed.”
Monsanto is currently conducting field trials of a new genetically modified version of the wheat in two states, U.S. data show. It planted 150 acres (61 hectares) of wheat in Hawaii last year that was genetically modified to tolerate glyphosate weedkiller. Another 300 acres of wheat engineered with Roundup tolerance and other traits is being tested in North Dakota this year.
The Roundup Ready wheat in the new field trials is “an entirely different event” than the escaped crop reported by the USDA, St. Louis-based Monsanto said. “This research is still in the very early phases and at least a decade away from commercial approval,” said Monsanto spokesman Lee Quarles.
The same GE technology is already widely used in soybeans and corn in the United States and allows farmers to spray their fields with weedkillers without harming the main crop.
“The first thing to know is it is perfectly safe. It was fully tested by Monsanto prior to 2005,” said Ronnie Coffman, professor of plant breeding and director of international programs of the college of agriculture and life sciences at Cornell University.
“Wheat farmers have wanted it all along, but there is the sense that the issue among the big wheat exporting nations is sort of, ‘You first.’
“The Americans don’t want to do biotech wheat before the Canadians do because they are afraid they might lose market share. The Canadians, the Americans, the Australians are all big wheat exporters and are all very sensitive to the market forces.”
U.S. Wheat Associates and the National Association of Wheat Growers issued a statement urging governments not to halt U.S. wheat imports based on the Oregon finding.
“Because of the isolated nature of this discovery, there appears to be little scientific reason for governments to suspend U.S. soft white wheat purchases,” the groups said.
“USDA made it clear that there is no evidence suggesting that this material has entered commercial supplies and that there is no health risk associated with it.”
However, consumer advocates said U.S. regulators have failed to protect the food supply from GE crop contamination, noting that Food and Drug Administration safety reviews of GE crops before market release are voluntary.
Freese said the situation in Oregon “shows the (total) inadequacy of the regulatory system for GM crops.”
Other concerns include the potential human and animal impacts of the rising use of Roundup as a herbicide, with more chemicals being used because more crops are now resistant.