Japanese historians slam sex-slave apology review


A group of Japanese historians Friday stood behind their government’s 1993 apology over wartime sex slavery, slamming Tokyo’s possible move to revise it as “unforgivable”.

The landmark apology, known as the Kono Statement because it was issued by then-Chief Cabinet Secretary Yohei Kono, acknowledged official complicity in the coercion of females from across Asia into a system of wartime brothels, an issue that draws particular resentment in South Korea.

On March 1, South Korean President Park Geun-hye warned Japan that it would face “isolation” if it pushed ahead with a move to revisit the apology.

But conservative Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s government has said evidence given by the “comfort women” — the euphemism for those forced to work in military brothels — that forms the basis of the apology is to be re-examined.

Respected historians say up to 200,000 women, mostly from Korea but also from China, Indonesia, the Philippines and Taiwan, were forced to serve as sex slaves in Japanese army brothels.

However, a minority of right-wing Japanese insist there was no official involvement by the state or the military and say the women were common prostitutes.

“It is unforgivable to retreat from the Kono Statement,” Yoshiaki Yoshimi, a professor of modern Japanese history at Chuo University, told academics and rights activists at a Tokyo conference.

“The latest historical documents can allow us to say that the military hurt the honor and dignity of many women.”

Hiroshi Hayashi, a politics professor at Kanto Gakuin University, said he and his fellow researchers discovered at least a dozen new documents proving that there was direct military involvement in the practice.

“There are many more, probably more than 6,000, undisclosed documents that had been stored by the Japanese government,” he said.

“The government has repeatedly said there are no documents remaining to show the military’s direct involvement in the issue. I must say this is an extremely disingenuous attitude.”

Their comments came a day after the U.S. ambassador to Japan, Caroline Kennedy, urged Tokyo and Seoul to patch up their troubled relations.

“I think that the two countries really should and will take a lead in this process, and the United States, being a close ally of both of them, is happy to help in any way that we can,” Kennedy said in an interview aired by NHK.

The Kennedy interview had reportedly been jeopardized after controversial remarks about wartime sex slavery by NHK head Katsuto Momii, who had called the practice “common in any country at war”.

  • phu

    The Japanese people really deserve better than this government… likewise the South Korean and Chinese people and their respective governments… and North Koreans, and Americans, and Russians, and… well, pretty much everyone is getting screwed by their officials right now, but this is a good example of poor leadership in several countries feeding off each other and continuously making things worse.

  • Carroll Price

    The sex slave story is mostly BS. There’s never yet been an occupying army that hasn’t been overrun by an army of willing prostitutes.

    • tiger

      which country are you from? I would love to occupy it.

    • Cousin Houdini

      Don’t say any stupid if you know nothing of history and genuine truth. Japanese Imperial Army is the only military in the world actually created and ran a sexual system unlike the other situations since ancient time!!

    • disigny

      As Korea war vet , I also spent some time in Japan. As I understand it, it wasn’t only the Japanese Imperial Army that had problems with young guys, faced with death, and looking for a fling. Our own Flying Tiger chief, during ww2, arranged something similar for his boys, mostly for health and discipline reasons Prostitution is legal in some countries. It’s mainly about preventing outright abuse.
      For those who think it is demeaning to women, I sugest focussing your efforts on eliminating “Wars”, which is simple if not easy. When the Chiefs can be prosecuted for murder, as they should be , (which of course implies real Laws) then wars will be few.

      • FunnyPunch

        If only the world would be so simple. The chiefs are almost never prosecuted.

  • Cheung Colleen

    When they say it’s common in every country, yes, it’s true. But, not when they had the highest rates of rape in history. That’s unbelievable and unacceptable

  • FunnyPunch

    Being a huge fan of Japan, I still have to say that there is no shame in apologizing for War Crimes. Quite the opposite. Admitting mistakes shows courage. Poland has appologized for killing Jews at Jedwabne, even this was minor incident compared to German War Crimes, and didn’t involve Polish government. So though I support current Japanese government, I have to condemn the revision of appologies.