South China Sea dispute in focus at Asia forum

China's assertive actions in staking its territorial claims prompt concern


Southeast Asia’s top diplomats kicked off a major regional forum on Sunday with a firm focus on trying to ease tensions with China over a territorial row, amid warnings that failure could lead to conflict.

Toxic smoke from uncontrolled burning of Indonesia’s enormous rain forests that has drifted across to neighboring countries was also expected to be on the agenda at the annual 10-member Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) foreign ministers’ meeting in Brunei’s capital.

The talks will expand on Monday and Tuesday to include the United States, China, Japan, Russia and other countries across the Asia-Pacific, providing the platform for hectic face-to-face diplomacy on many of the world’s hot-button issues.

As with previous regional gatherings, concerns over China’s increasingly assertive actions in staking its claims to most of the South China Sea were set to dominate.

Setting the tone for the event, a powerful arm of China’s state-run media warned the Philippines on Saturday that its defiance could lead to aggressive Chinese action.

“If the Philippines continues to provoke China . . . a counterstrike will be hard to avoid,” said a commentary that was run by the People’s Daily, the mouthpiece of the ruling Communist Party.

ASEAN members the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia and Brunei, as well as Taiwan, also claim parts of the strategically vital South China Sea.

The waterway, which is believed to sit atop vast deposits of oil and natural gas, has long been regarded as one of Asia’s potential military flash points and the escalating tensions in recent years have heightened concerns over potential battles for control.

The Philippines has been the most vocal in expressing alarm at China’s growing assertiveness, which has included an increased Chinese naval presence in the area, and it reacted angrily to the People’s Daily commentary.

“There is no place in the relations of civilized nations to use such provocative language. We call on China to be a responsible member in the community of nations,” Foreign Ministry spokesman Raul Hernandez said.

In a press release that was issued at the forum on Sunday, Philippine Foreign Affairs Secretary Albert Del Rosario said he had “expressed serious concern over the increasing militarization of the South China Sea.”

He said there was a “massive presence of Chinese military and paramilitary ships” at two groups of islets within the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone called Scarborough Shoal and Second Thomas Shoal.

Del Rosario described the Chinese military presence at these islets as “threats to efforts to maintain maritime peace and stability in the region.”

Del Rosario said the Chinese actions violated a pact made in 2002 in which rival claimants to the sea pledged not to take any actions that may increase tensions.

The declaration on conduct signed by ASEAN nations and China also committed rival claimants to resolve their disputes “without resorting to the threat or use of force.”

“We reiterate our continued advocacy for a peaceful and rules-based settlement of disputes in accordance with universally recognized principles of international law,” Del Rosario said.

ASEAN has been trying for more than a decade to secure agreement from China on a legally binding code of conduct that would govern actions in the South China Sea.

China has resisted agreeing to the code, wary of giving any concessions that may weaken its claim to the sea.

Nevertheless, Indonesian Foreign Minister Marty Natalegawa said ASEAN would continue to press its case with China in Brunei.

“We will be really zeroing in on the need for the code of conduct,” Natalegawa told reporters on Saturday.

He said that a code, while not a “magic wand,” would be an important tool in avoiding conflict.

“We need to manage and prevent miscalculations and unintended actions, reactions and (where) we have a huge furor and huge incident on our plate,” he said.

“That is too huge a risk to have, this . . . sense of anarchy, a sense of lawlessness.”

Meanwhile, U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry is expected to hold a series of rapid-fire meetings with his counterparts from the world’s major powers, including Russia’s Sergey Lavrov and China’s Wang Yi.

The United States has been frustrated in recent weeks by perceived Chinese and Russian help for fugitive intelligence leaker Edward Snowden, who is at Moscow’s airport after being allowed to leave the Chinese territory of Hong Kong.

Within ASEAN, a key focus at Brunei will be Indonesia’s forest fires, which this month caused Southeast Asia’s worst air pollution crisis in years.

Natalegawa said on Saturday that the fires had been greatly reduced and were coming under control.

  • hai_nguyen

    Given continued escalation of both Chinese behavior and act, let’s change characterization of their action from ” assertive ” to ” aggressive “.

    Being assertive implies confidence and bold expression while being aggressive indicates a ” behavior or a disposition, that is forceful, hostile or attacking. It may occur either in retaliation or without provocation.” according to Wikipedia.

    China is the only claimant in the South China Sea that attacked others without provocation ( took Paracel islands from Vietnam in 1974, killed 58 South Vietnamese defenders, took 8 islets from Vietnam in 1988, killed 68 construction workers, took Mischief shoal from the Philippines in 1998, took Scarborough shoal from the Philippines in 2012…). Its government, government controlled media not only molded extreme nationalism but, also expresses open hostilities, physical threats toward other claimants. China often fabricates and distorts others actions to give itself an over-killed retaliation opportunity.

    The word ” aggressive ” not only describes Chinese behavior and act more accurately, it also appropriately poses the question of regional and international responses: what does ASEAN and the civilized communities to do when a nation such as China is increasingly behaving and acting criminally and lawlessly? Talk and/or negotiation may not be enough!