China considers banning all unapproved Internet domains

Bloomberg

China’s government is moving to tighten its grip over the Internet as it rolls out draft rules that will effectively ban Web domains not approved by local authorities, including possibly the most widely used .com and .org addresses.

The Ministry of Industry and Information Technology is seeking feedback on regulations proposing that Internet domain names offering “domestic access” should only be provided by services supervised by the government, according to a notice posted on the regulator’s website. Domain names are web locations such as .net or .cn. Under the proposal, their providers have to apply to the ministry for approval before Web addresses are allowed to operate.

That could allow the government to monitor users’ activity and strengthen its control over what content is accessible, said Lento Yip, chairman of the Hong Kong Internet Service Providers Association, in an e-mail. The government of China, which has the world’s largest Internet population, blocks and filters content from local and overseas websites to keep a tight rein on citizens’ access to information via the so-called Great Firewall.

“The domain name system will work in the background for your every single click on the browser while the Great Firewall blocks outside content,” Yip said. “If this trend continues, we can predict that the Chinese network will soon become a big Intranet, totally monitored by a network ‘big brother. The authority can block all domain name servers outside of China (the Great Firewall) and allow only domestic domain name servers to serve Chinese Internet users requests.”

China employs one of the world’s most exhaustive Internet censorship regimes to suppress dissent and information deemed dangerous by the Communist Party. Social-media posts can be deleted and search terms blocked, and local Web users can’t access foreign websites, including those of Facebook and Twitter.

The ministry didn’t respond to a fax requesting comment on how the envisioned rules could affect Internet regulation.

The government has increased restrictions since President Xi Jinping took power three years ago, passing a security law establishing “cybersovereignty,” making retweets of rumors a crime and advancing regulations that would let companies in key sectors only use technology deemed “safe and controllable.”

Xi made personal visits last month to top state-run media outlets, which were called on to show loyalty to the party.

Authorities are seeking feedback on the draft until April 25. If adopted, the new rules mean that instead of blacklisting specific sites, the government will grant access only to websites that make it onto a white list, said Lokman Tsui, an assistant professor at the School of Journalism and Communication at the Chinese University of Hong Kong who has advised Google on freedom of expression and the Internet.

“This is a serious escalation and from what I can see would be an unprecedented move,” Tsui said in an e-mail. “It doesn’t seem exclusive to .cn.”

China last year erected regulations to supervise domain name registrars that operate within its borders, but the new rules would be the first time it has sought to extend its control over domains themselves, Tsui said. Article 37 of the proposed rules expressly puts domain names under central control by blocking any not registered with the authorities, he said.

The wording was vague, and it is unclear whether websites hosted outside the country and administered by The Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) — the quasi-governmental nonprofit gatekeeper for Web addresses — could be subject to the regulations. Yip said the regulations will likely apply only to websites hosted on servers within the country.

“Domain names engaging in network access within the borders shall have services provided by domestic domain name registration service bodies,” according to the rules published Friday. “For domain names engaging in network access within the borders, but which are not managed by domestic domain name registration service bodies, Internet access service providers may not provide network access services.”

  • GBR48

    White-listing is the obvious solution for any totalitarian dictatorship, but the Chinese people are no longer peasants. The development of a distributed internet with mobile devices as peer-to-peer nodes will be particularly advantageous in China, combining dynamic, torrent-style dissemination of the fundamentals of the internet backbone that are currently controlled and managed by ICANN and ISPs. Far more secure and distributed than Tor can ever be.

    The next iteration of the internet will probably begin (or may have begun) in China in response to state censorship.