Clear view of immigration bias

It was good to read about Hidenori Sakanaka, former director of the Tokyo Regional Immigration Bureau, essentially admitting that, despite its international treaty obligations, Japan is a determinedly anti-immigration country with a racial prejudice (“Population fixes have anti-foreign bias, official says,” May 17). Foreigners always knew it and said so, so Sakanaka’s confirmation reassures us that we haven’t been crazy all along. He sounds like a man who sees things clearly.

I have two main doubts about Japan’s population conundrum. First, government policy will not finagle a significant rise in the birthrate because it refuses to address or even admit the main impediment to children: the high cost of living here. Instead it wastes time with day care, maternity leave, etc., and even wants to make things more expensive by fueling inflation to kowtow to corporations.

Next, large-scale immigration as a population fix will never be approved here. Even if it is eventually, it will be too little, too late to be effective. Preferential regard is already given to immigration by foreigners of Japanese descent, a ridiculous “blood” principle in a formula of “return.” I suppose the conservatives’ concern about immigration is its threat to Japanese social homogeneity and the imagined complications that heterogeneity would cultivate. But homogeneity has always been a myth, so I cannot consider such concerns “natural” or reasonable. They are eminently unnatural.

Currently there are about 1.5 million registered foreigners in Japan. In addition, others are not registered — tourists and some who are not required to register because of the brevity or conditions of their stay. So the numbers are small in the overall population, less than 2 percent. But the number and proportion are irrelevant: We are a real part of Japan’s portrait.

Japan is already a nation of immigrants. Where did the Yamato people come from? They migrated from China and Korea. In any event, a shrinking population is not necessarily a bad thing. The politicians only want us to think it is.

grant piper

The opinions expressed in this letter to the editor are the writer’s own and do not necessarily reflect the policies of The Japan Times.

  • VivKay

    They are no doubt deeply patriotic and possessive about their living standards, their land, culture and traditions. Once doors are open to migrants, it’s hard to close them again due to vested interests. Japan is probably one of the sensible countries, and will end up with a sustainable population size with regards to their energy supplies, food security, and environmental protection. While the rest of the world is being devastated by over-population, Japan will survive with higher living standards and firm borders.