Prime Minister Shinzo Abe has, so far, managed to keep the outbreak of new coronavirus COVID-19 from damaging his hard-won relationship with China, but that’s getting more difficult with each new case confirmed in Japan.
Abe has taken a softer approach to China over the virus than the Trump administration, winning praise for Tokyo in Beijing. That resonates with his efforts to nurse Japan’s relationship with its giant neighbor and biggest trading partner back to health since he took office in 2012 amid the worst crisis in decades.
Unlike others including the United States, Australia and Singapore, Abe’s government has avoided a blanket ban on visitors from China, instead restricting entry from just two provinces. While acting quickly to evacuate its citizens from the outbreak’s epicenter in Hubei, Japan also used the planes to fly in aid packages to its neighbor.
The approach contrasted with that of Japan’s counterparts in the U.S., who have questioned China’s commitment to transparency via the crisis — leading to bilateral bickering. China is also keen to keep ties strong with Abe amid a painful trade war with the U.S. that has battered its economy.
“Japan’s attitude has been very helpful for China,” said Noriyuki Kawamura, a professor at Nagoya University of Foreign Studies. “China’s initial response to the virus was insufficient. The question is what Japan will do when those problems are exposed. Will it criticize China or close its eyes?”
China has shown its appreciation for Japan’s approach, marking an unusual interlude in a hot-cold relationship between Asia’s two biggest economies that has long rocked by disagreements over history and territory.
Personal touches, like a fragment of ancient Chinese poetry attached to aid packages from a Japanese group and a video of a Tokyo-based ballet troupe singing the Chinese national anthem, have won widespread praise on Chinese social media.
But as COVID-19 infections rise in Japan, Abe is likely to find his position harder to maintain, especially given that an earlier alert from China could have slowed the spread of the disease.
Before global warning flags were raised, thousands of Chinese tourists visited all parts of the nation, and have since been linked to cases of virus transmission. Three people have died in Japan so far from COVID-19 infections.
‘Cherry trees bloom’
Chinese visitors to Japan rose 22.6 percent in January from a year earlier, data released Wednesday showed. Even though infection numbers in China grew dramatically later in the month, Abe’s government only banned entry from Hubei province on Feb. 1.
While the virus outbreak initially provided an opportunity for Japan to show solidarity, it’s likely to interfere with Abe’s plans to host a state visit by President Xi Jinping intended to crown the seven-year slog to restore relations. Japanese officials have repeatedly said there’s no change to the plan to treat Xi with full state honors “when the cherry trees bloom” in early April, but both sides may find the trip harder to manage.
The virus also appears to be eating away at Abe’s long-solid voter support. A poll published this week by the conservative Yomiuri newspaper, which generally backs Abe, showed 52 percent of respondents were dissatisfied with the way the government has been handling the outbreak. His support rate dropped in all three media surveys published Monday.
The opposition Democratic Party for the People has called for a ban on all foreign people visiting from China. Former Prime Minister Yukio Hatoyama’s Twitter announcement that an organization he heads had donated a million masks to China was met with a barrage of online criticism amid an acute shortage of the annually sought items in Japan.
Some in Abe’s own ruling Liberal Democratic Party oppose Xi’s state visit, partly because of ongoing incursions by Chinese ships into Japan’s waters around the disputed Senkaku Islands.
An annual poll by think tank Genron NPO published in October found that 46 percent of Chinese had a favorable impression of Japan — the highest since the survey began in 2005 — as more tourists experience the country for themselves. Nearly 10 million Chinese visited Japan last year.
Almost 85 percent of Japanese respondents to the same poll said they had an unfavorable impression of China.
By contrast, Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokeswoman Hua Chunying said gratitude would bring their two peoples together.
“Since the outbreak of the epidemic, the Japanese government and people have expressed sympathy, understanding and support to us,” she told reporters on Feb. 4. “What the virus has done is cruel and will not last. What the people have done is touching and will be remembered forever.”
She later tweeted in Japanese about China sending testing kits to its neighbor, saying “there are no borders in the fight against the virus.”
But skeptics point out that there are still deep divisions between the countries, including over Japanese detained in China and severe restrictions on Muslims in the western region of Xinjiang. The territorial dispute over the Senkakus that brought them close to a military clash from 2012 to 2013 is no nearer resolution.
“Neither side has reduced its number of patrols close to the islands,” said Tsai Hsi-hsun, director of Tamkang University’s Graduate Institute of Japanese Political and Economic Studies in Taiwan. “They still don’t trust each other in terms of national security and that distrust is deeply ingrained on both sides even though, on the surface, the relationship looks better.”
In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.
Your news needs your support
Since the early stages of the COVID-19 crisis, The Japan Times has been providing free access to crucial news on the impact of the novel coronavirus as well as practical information about how to cope with the pandemic. Please consider subscribing today so we can continue offering you up-to-date, in-depth news about Japan.