Japan's whale restaurants cheer resumption of commercial hunts

by Karyn Nishimura


“Two sashimi, three steaks,” cries the waitress at one of Tokyo’s most famous whale restaurants during a frantic lunchtime service where Japan’s resumption of commercial whaling has cooked up new hope.

Mitsuo Tani has spent 46 of his 64 years preparing and cooking whale meat and hosts a mixed clientele at his restaurant: salarymen in white shirts gulping down a quick lunch before heading back to the office, single women, retired couples.

Whale steak is the most popular dish, at ¥980 ($9) — a thin rectangular piece of meat with as much rice, miso soup, vegetables and iced tea as the customer can eat. Also flying out of the kitchen is sashimi — raw slices of whale flesh, skin or liver.

Japan’s resumption of commercial whaling has infuriated foreign governments and campaigners, with activists saying one of the three species targeted is threatened with extinction and sub-populations of the other two are depleted.

But veteran chef Tani is keen to promote the health benefits of whale meat.

“It is five times lower in calories than beef, 10 times lower in cholesterol, two times less fat than chicken. It’s packed with iron. But abroad, people do not know this,” he said.

Not all would agree with Tani’s sales pitch, however. In 2015, when the Environmental Investigation Agency tested the mercury levels of whale meat sold in Japan, it found high levels of the toxic metal, among other toxins.

As he whipped up a “whale roast beef,” Tani explained that he had to move from Sendai after the 2011 tsunami and the price of whale meat soared amid a significant drop in supply.

In Tokyo, he has never had any problem procuring meat. While Japan was still part of the International Whaling Commission, the whales caught in Antarctic waters for “research” purposes still ended up as sashimi and steak on plates around the country.

Ironically, with Japan resuming commercial whaling off its own coast, the quantity of meat may decline.

Japan had set an annual quota of more than 600 whales while in the IWC.

The cap now stands at 227 until the end of the year — 52 minke, 150 Bryde’s and 25 sei whales.

It is not the only country carrying out hunts. Norway and Iceland have conducted hunts in recent years, and indigenous people from Alaska to Greenland also have allowed exemptions to the moratorium.

Hitting back at those who fear the resumption of commercial whaling will further endanger the mammals, Japanese authorities say the quotas have been set carefully “to keep the whale population at a sustainable level.”

“I’m scared that the quantity of whale meat will go down,” Tani admitted.

Another restaurant boss, Sumiko Koizumi, hailed the resumption of whaling as “an excellent thing” and said it was down to chefs to promote the meat and dream up new recipes.

Removing the stigma around the meat will make it easier for consumers, she said, “first because supermarkets will be more inclined to offer it and wholesalers will listen more to our needs and be in a position to meet them.”

Kenta Yodono, sales manager at whaling firm Kyodo, which runs the Japanese fleet’s flagship, said the commercial hunts will catch different species, each of which taste slightly different.

“The commercial species will be different and certain people might be concerned that they will not have the same taste. But in general, I think the quality will improve and we can respond to restaurants’ needs,” he said.

Yodono also acknowledged activists’ concerns about the cruelty of the hunts and said “the fishermen are conscious of the fact that the time the animal suffers should be reduced.”

Tani, however, fears for the immediate future of his industry because few chefs are training to acquire the specialized cooking skills required.

“With commercial whaling halted for more than 30 years, no one has got into the business and that will not happen overnight,” he said.

“Even if some people get into it now, it will take 30 years. And if they find the work too hard, they will stop. Whale needs to be well cooked or otherwise no one will start to eat it again,” Tani added.

Japan has defended the controversial whale hunt as a key part of its tradition and rich culinary heritage.

Tani agrees. “A country that does not preserve its food culture has no future.”

Coronavirus banner