BRUSSELS – Companies including Google, Facebook and Twitter could face European Union laws forcing them to be more proactive in removing illegal content if they do not do more to police what is available on the internet.
The European Union executive outlined in draft guidelines how internet firms should step up efforts with measures such as establishing trusted flaggers and taking voluntary measures to detect and remove illegal content.
Proliferating illegal content, whether because it infringes copyright or incites terrorism, has sparked heated debate in Europe between those who want online platforms to do more to tackle it and those who fear it could impinge on free speech.
The companies have significantly stepped up efforts to tackle the problem of late, agreeing to an EU code of conduct to remove hate speech within 24 hours and forming a global working group to combine their efforts remove terrorist content from their platforms.
Existing EU legislation shields online platforms from liability for the content that is posted on their websites, limiting how far policymakers can force companies, who are not required to actively monitor what goes online, to act.
“Online platforms need to significantly step up their actions to address this problem,” the draft EU guidelines say.
“They need to be proactive in weeding out illegal content, put effective notice-and-action procedures in place, and establish well-functioning interfaces with third parties (such as trusted flaggers) and give a particular priority to notifications from national law enforcement authorities.”
The guidelines, expected to be published at the end of the month, are non-binding but further legislation is not ruled out by next spring, depending on progress made by the companies.
However, a European Commission source said any legislation will not change the liability exemption for online platforms in EU law.
A spokesman for Twitter had no comment on the draft but pointed to the company’s latest data on its efforts to tackle abuse showing it is taking action on 10 times the number of abusive accounts every day compared to the same time last year.
Facebook and Google declined to comment.
The commission wants the companies to develop “trusted flaggers”— experienced bodies with expertise in identifying illegal content — whose notifications will be given high priority and could lead to the automatic removal of content.
It also encourages web companies to publish transparency reports with detailed information on the number and type of notices received and actions taken and says the commission will explore options to standardize such transparency reports.
The guidelines also contain safeguards against excessive removal of content, such as giving its owners a right to contest such a decision.
The commission wants companies to hone technology used to automatically detect illegal content so that the volume which needs to be reviewed by a human before being deemed illegal can be narrowed down.
In a time of both misinformation and too much information, quality journalism is more crucial than ever.
By subscribing, you can help us get the story right.
With your current subscription plan you can comment on stories. However, before writing your first comment, please create a display name in the Profile section of your subscriber account page.