U.S. Supreme Court blocks Louisiana abortion restrictions


The Supreme Court on Friday blocked restrictions affecting doctors in Louisiana that could have forced all but one of the state’s abortion clinics to close.

In what reproductive-rights advocates hope may foreshadow a major legal victory later this year, the court temporarily reinstated a trial judge’s order blocking a new Louisiana law that requires doctors to obtain a formal affiliation with a local hospital.

An appeals court had said the previous week that the law could be enforced.

Abortion-rights supporters say the law was designed to shut down abortion clinics by requiring hospital “admitting privileges” that are difficult to secure.

“These underhanded tactics to cut off women’s access to safe, legal abortion simply cannot stand,” Nancy Northup, president of the Center for Reproductive Rights, said in a statement. The center represents the Louisiana clinics challenging the law in court.

Justice Clarence Thomas was the sole member of the Supreme Court to publicly dissent against the court’s one-sentence order in the case.

The Supreme Court is considering an almost identical case in Texas with national implications.

Friday’s order came two days after the justices heard arguments in the Texas case — involving actions by the same federal appeals court, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans — and just hours after they voted in a private meeting on the outcome of that case.

The Texas case also involves hospital admitting privileges, as well as separate requirements that abortion facilities meet the same strict standards as surgical centers.

The Supreme Court has sent mixed signals about its thinking.

Although it temporarily blocked the surgical-center requirement, it has allowed the provision on admitting privileges take effect throughout most of the state.

The majority of justices said the court’s action on Friday was “consistent” with the June 2015 halt of the Texas surgical-center provision, the second time the court suspended that part of the Texas law.

“For the third time in a little over a year, the Supreme Court has stepped in to preserve women’s ability to get the constitutionally protected health care they need,” Northup said.

Justice Anthony Kennedy is widely expected to provide the pivotal vote in the Texas case.

Abortion rights advocates hope Friday’s vote for the clinics in Louisiana could signal that he will also provide a decisive fifth vote in favor of the Texas clinics.

Friday’s order will put Louisiana’s law on hold until the justices prepare a ruling in the Texas case, expected by the end of June.

The Louisiana law was signed by former Gov. Bobby Jindal, a Republican, in 2014.

  • GBR48

    One of the endless attempts by the Repulsive party to undermine American law by underhand means, Why are they surprised that Trump is leading the race to head their party? The rest of them have been behaving as badly as him for years. From outside the US, it looks like a perfect fit. They deserve each other.