/

Murayama, Kono assail revisionism, urge Abe to uphold their apologies in entirety

by

Staff Writer

Two former leaders who issued historic apologies for the nation’s past lambasted revisionist attempts to rewrite history on Tuesday, urging Prime Minister Shinzo Abe to stand by the statements they delivered when they were in office.

In a joint appearance at the Japan National Press Club in Tokyo, former Chief Cabinet Secretary Yohei Kono and former Prime Minister Tomiichi Murayama went on to urge the administration to withdraw its contentious security-related bills from the Diet.

In 1993, Kono issued an apology for Japan’s use of “comfort women,” females forced to work at Japanese wartime brothels, and Murayama in 1995 delivered an apology for Japan’s aggression against other Asian countries and for its colonial rule of the Korean Peninsula.

Many right-leaning politicians have picked over semantics, arguing that private-sector brokers, not the Japanese Imperial military, were the main parties that recruited the victims — thereby playing down the overall responsibility of Japanese authorities.

Kono confronted this, saying the vast majority of the females were forced to work at the brothels against their will, and were typically coerced into the activity through deception and human trafficking.

The denials that the women were coerced have “badly damaged the honor of the Japanese people,” Kono told the reporters who packed the main hall of the press club.

Some people “try to deny what is obvious to everybody, or try to play it down by saying (other countries) have done similar things. I have keenly felt the damage such an attitude has done to the honor of the Japanese people,” Kono said.

They addressed Abe’s dance over the extent of Japan’s responsibility for events in the region early last century. The prime minister had once indicated he might revise or withdraw Kono’s apology, and has additionally said he does not agree with the entirety of Murayama’s war apology.

However, facing criticism at home and abroad, Abe now says he upholds both the Kono and the Murayama statements “as a whole,” while avoiding elaborating further.

Abe plans to issue a statement of his own in August to mark the 70th anniversary of the end of World War II. Whether he will express remorse over Japan’s aggression against other Asian nations and its colonial rule of the Korean peninsula has been a focus of public attention.

Murayama said he opposes Abe’s reinterpretation of the war-renouncing Constitution to allow Japan to exercise the right of collective self-defense, or the right to use force to aid an ally under attack even if Japan itself is not being attacked.

Kono, meanwhile, urged Abe to withdraw controversial security bills and appealed to him not to try to bulldoze them through the Diet.

Murayama, who was the head of the Social Democratic Party, served as prime minister from June 1994 to January 1996.

Murayama said his main aim in issuing the 1995 statement was not to extend an apology, but to “search our souls over the past history” and explain Japan’s outlook for the future.

“I was determined to quit as prime minister if I could not achieve this, because there would have been no meaning for me to serve as the prime minister” without carrying this out, Murayama said.

His Cabinet was a coalition government of the SDP, the Liberal Democratic Party and the now-defunct New Party Sakigake.

Murayama said all Cabinet members, including those from the LDP, approved his war apology statement and that he “had never expected” that opposition against his and Kono’s statements would be brought up again two decades later.

  • Liars N. Fools

    Although eclipsed by Nippon Kaigi and Abe Shinzo and his ilk, Murayama and Kono still speak with moral authority. Truth. So easy for most. So difficult for Abe.

  • Richard Solomon

    If Abe really upholds the apologies as he claims, he should read them in their entirety. I would bet he cannot/will not because he does not really believe in them. He claims that his ‘heart aches’ over what was done to Comfort Women. But he will not take any concrete steps to make amends: meet with them, announce the building of a memorial in their honor, offer them reparations paid by the government.

    I agree he is doing ‘a dance.’. He is trying to finesse his way through the polarities of revisionism vs true taking of responsibility for Japan’s actions during WW II. As long as he is doing this, there are no prospects for true reconciliation with other Asian countries or their citizens.

    • Clickonthewhatnow

      There has been reconciliation with Asian countries, though, and I doubt the two people think about most in regards to this will ever completely reconcile with Japan as it makes for an easy story to drudge up whenever their government has done something wrong. I’m not saying an apology – or renewal of the apology – or whatever – shouldn’t be done, but let’s get real, it would be done for the world at large, it wouldn’t make a lick of difference with China and Korea. China would still send its students to the “We hate Japan” museum to keep them from remembering the horrible things their own country does.

  • leconfidant

    On the issue of building a stronger military capacity for Japan, I entirely sympathise with Abe-san. China’s military expenditure is going through the roof and they seem to be in ongoing dispute with every country around them, so if Japan want to develop capability to respond to that, they need to do something.

    But given that Japan’s war crimes are fairly well known to the rest of the world, it’s just rather astonishing to meet so many well-intentioned, well-educated Japanese who are completely unaware of how utterly negatively they are viewed in respect to WWII.

    The west do their own share of historical revisionism, a fact we ought always to bear in mind. Why has the west broadly been forgiven for their own colonialism? Because they admit to it. Because children in elementary and high school learn about it as part of curriculum. We did slavery, we did colonial exploitation, we subdued China in the opium wars,

    But Japan went out to dominate and enslave Asia. They did it well. They did it so well that nobody has forgotten for a hundred years. Western colonialism arguably gave something back to the countries they occupied. They all got a boost in industry, medicine, technology and rule-of-law. Japan can make no such claims.

    Nobody has pleasant memories of Japanese occupation. Korea’s culture was completely destroyed under the Japanese. Everywhere they went, they are remembered as a psychopathic tyranny. This actually happened. It did.

    People trust criminals like the UK and the USA who generally admit to what they did. They don’t trust criminals who are in denial. Until Japan starts remembering, the rest of their neighbors will want to remember it for them.

    Now inasmuch as Japan’s military effort seems to depend on cooperation with these same neighbors around them, who they comitted their crimes against, WHY DOES JAPAN WANT TO EXACERBATE THEIR DIPLOMATIC TIES WITH THEIR NEIGHBORS AT EXACTLY THE TIME WHEN THEY REALLY NEED INTERNATIONAL COOPERATiON?

    • Revelation

      This is quite possibly one of the best responses I’ve read in regard to Japan’s past war crimes, and yes, I also agree that Japan should bolster their military especially with their neighbor China gradually growing more and more ambitious.

      And we can all figure it is not Japan’s intention to raise the ire of their neighbors, but Abe wishes for Japan to stand proudly on its own as much as possible, which is why he does not bend despite being pressured to acknowledge in detail Japan’s past crimes. To him, it’s a severe blow to Japan’s pride than anything else, because for him and a lot of Japanese, unfortunately, they don’t think they did anything wrong. That has to change and it should begin with honest education instead of this historical whitewashing plaguing schools far and wide.

  • Nicholas Pediaditakis

    Version:1.0
    StartHTML:0000000167
    EndHTML:0000004545
    StartFragment:0000000457
    EndFragment:0000004529
    niko15@bellsouth.net

    The
    amazing true story of Beate Serota

    In a
    previous article I wrote about humanity ‘s looming troubles

    But as I
    have said I am optimistic.

    Here is
    an inspiring story of a young girl’s special accomplishment -one
    of many she did – , giving all of us hope.

    She was
    just 22 graduate from Mills college in Oakland at the end of the war
    with japan in 1945 .She was fluent in Japanese .( She was
    also fluent in Russian , English ,German , French as
    well Italian) She was desperate to reunite with the
    separated from her parents ,stranded in the devastated
    Tokyo,where she had left them just before the war
    to complete her college in USA .Her father an immigrant
    from Russia by way of Austria was employed as an important
    pianist in the imperial college of Japan. Beate
    Sirota managed to get employed as an interpreter in
    General’sMcArthur staff . She ,together with two more young
    lawyers were then assigned by him ,to write the new constitution
    of the defeated Japan !! She ,together with the other two, by
    working day and night ,did a brilliant job in a few days ,
    insuring dignity and equality for the Japanese women in
    the years to come ,who previously were treated like hired
    serfs.Japan which for centuries was a tribal country of
    warriors full of Shoguns and Samurais and
    swords cutting regularly each others heads or if felt
    slighted kneeling and opening their belly with a sharp knife !.
    They called the”Honored “act Seppuku. We also know it as
    Harakiri .

    .Japan now
    under her new constitution which outlawed war , prospered
    as a peaceful civilized enterprising nation been in peace
    now for seventy long years. Beate Serota now Gordon
    , as a citizen of our country, went ahead to
    accomplish much in arts and cultural international
    understanding. She died 1n 2012 worried about peace and women’s
    rights . For good reason . Recently the current Chieftain
    in Japan who still considers the previous carnage of the
    past ,as great Glories , tried recently to change her
    constitution so japan be able to start again wars !
    Fortunately his effort was defeated by the now
    sophisticated citizens of his country . The lessons of
    the story; A single brilliant and good faith person can
    make a mind boggling difference .The second lesson ;
    War is neither necessary nor inevitable .And a third ;
    citizens do not buy foolishness as often as in the past As about
    Beate Serota Gordon ;she did find her parents alive and well.
    Herself she lived a long happy and accomplished life with her
    beloved husband who himself died a few months before she
    did .

    When at home in
    a quiet moment think about it Like I have done myself .

  • JimmyJM

    Bravo to Messrs Kono and Murayama. They did their best to set Japan on the right path. Even the Emperor and Crown Prince have indicated Mr. Abe should remember history as it was and not how he wishes it were. Much of Japan’s future will be determined by what Mr. Abe says in August.

  • timefox

    China is building a new base in the vicinity of the Senkaku Islands . In this timing , it would be what their purpose of such a remark ?

    Kono perpetrator who accounted shame Japan in cooperation with the South Korean government . Murayama ringleader who killed a lot of Japanese in the Great Hanshin Earthquake .

    They claim it is not than are for Japan .