Saitama city blocks ‘one-sided’ exhibit on ‘comfort women’

by

Staff Writer

The city of Niiza, Saitama Prefecture, is refusing to let a citizens’ group use a municipal facility for an exhibition on “comfort women,” claiming that the display would promote the views of a particular group on the controversial wartime practice.

A municipal official also said the exhibition’s target audience — junior high school students — is too young to be taught about the wartime practice, through which women and girls, mostly from Asia, were forced to serve in Japanese military brothels.

The exhibition, which had been scheduled to start Friday in Furusato Niiza Hall, was aimed at informing teenagers about the issue through explanatory panels, photographs and written testimonies of former comfort women, according to the organizer, the Niiza Gender Equality Network.

The panels were created by the Tokyo-based Women’s Active Museum on War and Peace, which is known as Wam.

“We thought it was a good idea to remind people of (the comfort women issue) as this year marks the 70th anniversary of the end of World War II,” Yoko Tanimori of the Niiza citizens’ group said, arguing the city’s move infringes on the right to freedom of expression.

Niiza officials, meanwhile, say the event would have led students to form a one-sided opinion on the issue.

“If we allowed the exhibition by one specific group, it would mean that we are agreeing with one opinion while everyone has a right to form their own views,” said Tadahiko Koyama, director of the Niiza Municipal Government’s education and general affairs division.

He added that the exhibition didn’t match the city’s rules for use of the facility, which is to promote citizens’ works related to art and culture.

  • Ash

    ‘A municipal official also said the exhibition’s target audience — junior high school students — is too young to be taught about the wartime practice, through which women and girls, mostly from Asia, were forced to serve in Japanese military brothels’

    Oh, come on..

    ‘Niiza officials, meanwhile, say the event would have led students to form a one-sided opinion on the issue’

    Well, it’s not like many of the citizen hasn’t already formed a one-sided opinion (which favors Japan, of course) due to the current education system. Greenlight the exhibition, let the students attend and they can form their own opinion.

  • Pete Wagner

    Who funds all these anti-Japanese groups whose purpose is to create tensions between the East Asians? Follow the money all the way back to the US banks.

    • Hendrix

      nonsense, you are divorced from reality if you believe that…

      • Pete Wagner

        There are fools and tools. Not sure which you are.

      • kension86

        Well, you would also be a conspiracy theorist to suggest that US is behind this without evidence…

      • Pete Wagner

        Evidence is the military occupation. But requires a logic train that you may not be capable of.

      • left nut

        Per your comment… the US is sabotaging it’s own efforts to re-pivot (to counter China’s influence) in Asia by pitting it’s two closest allies in East Asia against each other and anyone who question or does not agree with you… is a fool or tool, who lacks the mental capacity to connect the “dots”

        Rather than responding to kension86, with an insult, you could have provided sources (regardless of how questionable it maybe to others…). It would have done your credibility a service…

      • Pete Wagner

        In a nutshell, the US is struggling to maintain dominance as it’s only two tools of power are it’s military façade and continued global acceptance of the fiat dollar. Both are tenuous due to the lack of US manufacturing base and broad American institutional inefficiencies. The two geo-political linchpins of East Asia are Korea and Japan, with Korea being the easiest one to pull (reunification). The Japan linchpin is pulled only secretly via potential deals struck with Russia and China. The US will continue to do what it can to keep ROK and Japan under it’s thumb and those linchpins from being pulled. The comfort women issue, rape of Nanking, etc. not unlike “the holocaust” are not historical but molded socio-political tools to control the present geo-political situation. The small island squabbles are easily worked out (via joint enterprise zones). Ford of course was right when he said history is bunk. Look forward not back. A united East Asia would turn this world around for the better. Only the zionist/yankee tyrants are against this.

      • batbrewer

        Oh, you’re a Holocaust denier! Well that *is* a surprise, given that you seemed so intelligent up to now.

      • Pete Wagner

        6M jews gassed but no physical evidence of it? Just all those old “survivors” to say they saw it but somehow escaped? Sorry to burst your bubble, it’s bunk.

      • left nut

        Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts, I sincerely appreciate it.

        I have my own suspicions/theories on some back door dealings to keep things in a continuous cycle of mistrust in East Asia (From the onset of the Japan’s surrender in WW2), but have not gone as far as to paint a picture with connected dots (I simply lack the hard facts).

        I do share your sentiment that untied East Asia (or a more co-operative East Asia) would be for the better.

        However, we are going to have to agree to disagree on the socio-political points.

        Thanks again for sharing.

      • Pete Wagner

        Find a good open forum and engage and observe. You’ll start to learn the tactics and dichotomies.

      • left nut

        I’ll do that, I am always open to reading/hearing/debating different perspectives.

        Cheers.

    • batbrewer

      Ah yes, the same US that is despairing at its Asian allies’ inability to get along because of these tensions — is actually deliberately spending money to *create* the tensions in order to, uh, make money! Brilliant! Nothing gets past you, does it? Now tell us about the mind-control chemtrails and how Obama is a lizard from the planet Tharg.

      • Pete Wagner

        Maybe you missed the first day of Geo-politics 101.

      • batbrewer

        Your devastatingly incisive riposte leaves me speechless.

  • Hendrix

    More behind the scenes pressure from the dark hand that controls Japan, namely the right wing nuts who go all the way to the top of government… no way will they let this exhibition go ahead, they dont want young Japanese waking up now do they? …

  • Forest2014

    Korean version comfort stations existed during Vietnam War. called Turkish Bath, or Welfare Center exclusive for then-Korean troops in Saigon. Lets see How Korean gvernment and stupid anti-Japan groups hande this, Hope they dont hide this time as they did all the issues of comfort women victims during Korean war . People would soon realize what are the real issues here when we start see comfort women memorial statues here and there in Vietnam and one in fornt of korean embassy in Vietnam. Morons!

    • R0ninX3ph

      Oooh oooh the “other people did bad things so its okay that we did it too” argument! I love this one. Its like a three year old stealing candy then claiming its okay because Billy did it too.

      Just to be clear, nobody is saying that it is okay that any other nation employed prostitutes to serve their militaries….

      • Forest2014

        Your response is very typical and stereotype excuse for bashing only Japan. So tired of hearing of it.
        Rape and Sex slavery happened everywhere everytime during wars. So tell me why only Japan? Huh?

      • R0ninX3ph

        Nice straw man there.

        I agree, ALL countries should have their dirty washing aired. But that isn’t what you are saying. You are saying that its mean and not nice to pick on Japan! And are instead just trying to deflect the issue.

        Perhaps if Japan took the lead, and had open discussion about it, other countries would be also willing to have the same open discussions. If Japan opens the discussion, you think it makes them look weak, but the irony is, if they openly discussed it, they would be the ones to actually be strong.

        You’re right though, Japan shouldn’t be singled out, but this website is a Japan based news source, so of course their focus is going to be on Japan.

        You might notice that below I replied to a comment saying I support exhibits that display ALL, and not just Japan. But, nah, you’d rather just attack me and misrepresent my arguments because you think I hate Japan.

        The fact is, I love Japan, I think its a nation with the possibility to be an amazing world leader. But part of that, is also taking the bruises from its past on the chin.

      • Forest2014

        Refer to this english wiki by googling the title below

        List of war apology statements issued by Japan

        and Read Kono and Murayama Testimony again and repeat your naive statement when and if those are really revised by Japanese Cabinet. Till then, suggest doing the same to Korea, China, Russia, USA, all other western ex-empires

      • R0ninX3ph

        Forest2014, you haven’t understood anything I said. I am suggesting that other nations do the same. I agree the Kono statement admitted it, but as they say, “actions speak louder than words”, and 22 years on, as the world looks on, the current right wing Government is doing everything in their power to backpedal on that statement.

        Including forcing themselves into the office of an author of a history book demanding he change the information in the book.

        While yes, the Kono statement admitted certain things, the recent actions, including people in power like Toru Hashimoto making public statements going directly AGAINST the Kono statement, makes it clear that either 1 of two things is happening:

        1) The Kono statement is not to be trusted and it was not a true statement at the time.

        OR

        2) The current Government and other people in positions in power do not agree with it, and wish to revise it.

        So which is it? Were the comfort women coerced, like the Kono statement admitted? OR, was the Kono statement a lie and secretly Japan still denies the use of prostitutes whether forced or not.

      • Forest2014

        How the F*** China and Korea and all others make such noise despite those statements were not touched any at all YET. Abe didnot make any statement YET.
        Sure I have my personal opinion regarding how stupid Kono statement was.
        I should enjoy my free right to believe how things happended, just like everybody

      • Steve

        Totally agree 0nix 3ph, brilliantly put.

        See my comments elsewhere.

        There are too many “Country X does/did it too, so …… ” / “Japan is better/worse than Country X because…..” type comments on this JT board. The fact is, we live in Japan, and in my case my Japanese new-born son lives in Japan. I don’t much care if Country X is or was worse than Japan by some arbitrary degree of comparison (you’d have to define what “Japan” and “country X” actually meant in the first place anyway), No, I want the best for me and my son here!

        So let’s get our own house in order, let’s man up and be open about these things and sort them out head on (instead of the wingnut “call the waaahmbulance, they are insulting the honour of Japan mummy!” crybaby view.) Then, as 0nix 3ph says, other countries might come on board following Japan’s lead, a real debate about women’s rights and equality might ensue (imagine that, Japan taking the lead, taking responsibility, putting things right internationally, not following the yanks and europeans….)

        But no, this is unlikely in the current climate. So whilst “Japan” desperately attempts to show it isn’t a laughing stock at State level by defending laughing stock points of view, the women themselves, who don’t really care about all this pompous, peacocking (i.e. alpha male) honour of this or that nation state, are totally ignored. Real women I might add…., real flesh and blood human beings, able to suffer the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune and stuff. There is no honour in that. Or if this is the “bushido honour” of Japan as defined by the rightwing, it is a disgrace and I want no part of it for me and my son.

        But they weren’t coerced, and they were just unfortunate prostitutes at a difficult time I hear them say…… Sheeeeesh, they have no idea have they…… Yep, all free agents, all made the choice to do this by themselves, all able to leave at any time, all able to refuse this or that man whenever they wanted, even the ones recruited in nefarious circumstances by “non-Japanese” agents could report this to the Japanese military and were obviously then free to go, the Japanese military totally in the dark about all these shenanigans and underhand dealings (its a wonder they managed to keep hold of korea so long !), all these women only giving their testimonies now because they sniff some cash in it (once a lying prostitute, always a lying prostitute eh?)

        Japan does not need these people, they are not the true patriots. They only want control and to restrict plural debate. Ergo, they only want a “Japan” which won’t be able to punch its weight on the international stage.

      • Forest2014

        Where are you from Steve? Have you ever thought of Japanese and Japanese americans living in California Glandale,、NJ, They have their kids suffering from buing actually burried on the streets.

      • R0ninX3ph

        “Where are you from Steve? Have you ever thought of Japanese and Japanese americans living in California Glandale,、NJ, They have their kids suffering from buing actually burried on the streets.”

        I know plenty of Japanese Americans, I have plenty of friends who are of Japanese heritage from California, and not one of them, ever, has been bullied over things that Japan did during the war.

        Do you know why? Because they are AMERICAN. They aren’t Japanese… Even if your little right-wing brain thinks of them as Japanese, and the Zainichi Koreans as Korean (even though they have lived in Japan for generations) doesn’t make it so.

      • Forest2014

        Really? I know plenty of Japanese AND Japanese-AMERICANS living there telling those. So you are saying Japanese AMERICANS taking legal actions to remove comfort women statues are telling lies Huh?

      • Forest2014

        BTW, What do you know about Zainichi Korean?
        and how could you possibly think them Japanese when they donot think themselves Japanese, nor want to be Japanese? Look into mirror if you want to find how strawman looks like.

      • R0ninX3ph

        I don’t blame them for not wanting to be “Japanese” the way they are treated by people like you, spouting hate regarding them.

        Freedom of speech is one thing, spewing hate towards specific groups of people should not, and will not, ever be tolerated.

        But, there isn’t any point arguing with a Net-Uyoku Right Wing whackadoodle. Besides, you don’t know me, you don’t know my history, you just assume anyone who says anything against the conservative view point of Japan is evil and hates Japan.

        You can reply further to me, but I will not engage with someone who does not want to have a discussion, even with someone who agrees partially with you.

        I agree that all countries should hang out their dirty laundry, I believe all countries should admit to sexual slavery if they permitted it either officially or unofficially. I do not agree with forcing women to work as prostitutes, and that is the crux of the issue “Forest2014”.

        It does NOT matter whether the women were forced or they were prostitutes, they could not leave that situation. That makes it slavery. Yes, it is the same situation that occurs now in many nations, even your lovely Japan.

        I do not say every other nation is perfect, I admit they all have faults, and I repeat my previous statement. This site is a Japan based news source, it is not strange for them to be focusing on Japan.

        Enjoy living in your closed off little world, where you think everything is roses and unicorns. Good luck for the future.

  • Tochifu Tadashige

    If the Women’s Active Museum on War and Peace (Wam) really, truly cared about educating Japanese youth about violence against women, they would be organizing an exhibit on all known cases of ongoing atrocities against women around the world , and/or a historical exhibit on wartime violence against women in many different countries by different perpetrators (with detailed and fair analyses of available evidence and testimonies). But they never do. As far as I can tell, all they’ve organized so far are events after events on the Japanese/East Asian comfort women issue. For that alone, yes, they are shamelessly biased.

    • DR Jensen

      You’re right. If they really, truly cared they would do everything your way and obscure the ugly truth that the Japanese army systematically raped and pillaged its way across Asia. This group’s bias towards the truth is truly shameless. What nerve ! What gall !
      I hope you will continue to call them out in the future so we can all get a good laugh (at your expense).

      • Tochifu Tadashige

        I believe it’s actually possible to highlight, not obscure, the extent of damage brought on by the Japanese army by drawing comparisons to other cases, as long as the data and evidence presented are trustworthy. I do think, though, that it’s hypocritical (and intellectually lazy) to single out the Japanese army, and that at this point, no one has a sufficiently concrete understanding of what exactly the Japanese army did on a systematic basis on the one hand, and on a sporadic basis on the other. How exactly was sexual violence (how do we define it?) committed, and do we count just the civilians, or also the prostitutes (I am not using this term disparagingly–in my mind, it is simply an occupation, a way to earn a living) as victims? Who in the local population benefited by collaborating with the Japanese army (it would be naive to think that there were absolutely zero collaborators)? I am asking these questions not to discount any acts of violence, but because like you, I want to pursue the truth.

      • R0ninX3ph

        I dunno, I think they have a point, a complete exhibit about sexual crimes against women regarding all nations, but not solely on Japan isn’t a bad thing.

        As I said above, the argument always used is “others did bad things so our bad things aren’t bad either!”. Well, if we had more exhibits that exposed ALL the bad things, then they can’t use that argument anymore.

    • KobayashiDamien TakijiLucas

      So when the German state educates its citizens about the holocaust it should at the same time provide information about all instances of mass murder committed by states over the last 100-200 years or so?Grow up mate

      • Tochifu Tadashige

        Actually, that would not be a bad idea, although one or two centuries seem too short of a time period (seriously). Israel would certainly object (and let me clarify–I am not an anti-Semite), though, because it needs the Holocaust to remain an incomparable and ineffable incident in order to help justify the presence of the Israeli state. While it is true that the Holocaust was truly terrible particularly in that it called for the extermination of an entire group of people, I also believe that we need to develop a much more nuanced and concrete understanding of what humans have done to each other throughout history. How would Palestinians feel about your comment? Have you thought about that? (Mind you, I have no personal connections to Palestine, either.) I just don’t like the myopia that seems to be invading the minds of many people who think of themselves as compassionate, intelligent, and thoughtful–are they really?

  • timefox

    About guarantee money, South Korea should just pass comfort women the money which South Korea received from Japan by the Japan-ROK Basic Relations Treaty. Although the South Korean President’s father did not do it, it is not what present Japan should perform instead. The Japanese government’s apology to comfort women is also executed. Moreover, life assistance to comfort women was also supported in Asian Women’s Fund.

    Since this is a problem in South Korea, it should just support a life of all the comfort women in whom the South Korean government contains U.S. Forces comfort women.

    They are not sex slaves. They are not comfort women.
    They are professional camp follower. They are prostitute.

    By the way, There is a record by which a consolation place by the Korean Army existed in the time of Vietnam War in an American official document.

    This is the letter sent to the Korean Army commander in chief from American military headquarters in Saigon in 1969.

    An American commander is telling as follows by the letter.

    “The Turkish Bath was a Republic of Korea Army Welfare Center for the sole benefit of Korean Troops.”

    If it’s exhibited about a comfort woman, it should be exhibited about these Korean Army comfort woman and comfort woman of U.S. forces at the time of Korean War, too.

    • R0ninX3ph

      Looks like I get to copy-paste my exact same response to you again timefox.

      “Oh timefox…. I was hoping you’d be here. Oh… What am I saying, I knew you would be here. You saw the words “Comfort Women” and you just had to come in and bleat your little right wing sheep mantra.

      I have said this before, and I will keep saying it again, it doesn’t matter if they were prostitutes or if they were forced. Prostitutes, even when paid, are still often sexual slaves. They are not able to freely leave the “employ” of their masters.

      This is a problem nowadays with prostitution, and you can bet your bottom dollar that it was definitely a problem during the war under their military masters. Whether they were paid or not, does not matter! These women would not have been allowed to just say “Alright boss. I am finished, I am going back to my home”.

      I mean, I’m not surprised that right wing Japanese thinkers don’t really care about this point though. Women in Japan, even now, are often treated terribly in regards to sexual harassment and workplace harassment, so why would timefox care about what happened to women over 70 years ago?”

      Still not getting it? It doesn’t matter if they were professional prostitutes or coerced. Prostitutes are not free. They are more often than not, bound into servitude to their masters/pimps/”employers”, and are not free to leave that service. If it is true now, in the modern world when we are far more sensitive to the issues of women, why the hell would it suddenly be different 70 years ago?

      • Forest2014

        Just a reminder. S.Korea is the country where professional prostitues called for freedom of professions through demonstration street march.

        I didnt mean to disgrace the country and the people there. just pointing out your naiveness in your argument style. boy

      • R0ninX3ph

        Legalising and protecting prostitution is a GOOD thing. As currently they are not free.

        The point of providing them with legal protections is to make it a safe profession, which currently, it is not. There is nothing inherently wrong with selling sex. It happens in a large amount of first world nations, sex can be just as much a commodity as anything else.

        BUT, the people must be doing it of their own free will and must be allowed to stop at any point, of their own free will.

  • J.P. Bunny

    “The display would promote the views of a particular group on the controversial wartime practice.” Well, isn’t that what most exhibitions tend to do, promote the idea, thoughts, views, hopes, etc. of those putting on the exhibitions? If junior high students are old enough to be taught moral education and “love of country” in school, then they are old enough to look at a historical exhibition, and form their own opinions.

  • Ron NJ

    Let me guess, you’re a Holocaust denier as well?

  • Ron NJ

    http://uskoreainstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/2013-0815-Halpin-Comfort-Women.pdf
    The claims of the group which you have linked to are directly contravened by RR-120 (Allied Translator and Interpreter Section (ATIS), Supreme Commander for the Allied Powers (SCAP), “Amenities in the Japanese Armed Forces,” Research Report 120, November 15, 1945, p. 27), which is also specifically mentioned by the Interagency Working Group’s “Researching Japanese War Crimes” introductory essays (http://www.archives.gov/iwg/japanese-war-crimes/introductory-essays.pdf ), both of which are far more authoritative sources than the “Society for the Dissemination of Historical Fact”.

    • Forest2014

      Hello.
      The Link was to briefly present what COMFORT WOMEN in KOREA (directly managed by then-South Korean Government to serve for UN/US Troops) during KOREAN WAR were like and how Korea treating the same sex slavery victims.
      Thanks for your meaningless links, especially the one of infamous Dennis Halpin, who supposed to be expert on Korea amazingly voices nothing about Korean version.
      Can’t help though. nobody else, no organizations, UN human right commitees, says the world about them. What a wonderful world!

  • Obviously many Japanese have difficulties with democracy. Ok, there are people who don’t believe in the CW story. But they have their voice expressed almost everyday in Sankei or Yomiuri. That’s definately a one-sided opinion. The essence of democracy and freedem of speech, however, is: you can’t say yours is the only truth. So why don”t let the other “one-sided” opinion expressed? The Japanese banned not only this exhibition but also “Unbroken” by A. Jolie. Is this still a free country? I strongly doubt it.

    • Tochifu Tadashige

      In my experience, municipal facilities in Japan tend to be extra cautious about not appearing to take sides on anything that is potentially divisive (religion, politics, and the like). They are only willing to host innocuous singing groups, cooking classes, art exhibitions, etc. I guess the idea is to cater to all tax payers as evenly as possible, although I personally don’t necessarily agree with that way of thinking. In any case, I wonder how comparable this Saitama case is to “Unbroken.”

  • johnniewhite

    It is not just ‘one sided opinion’ — the majority of Japanese people have realised that this is a dirty political battle that is fanned by Asahi Shimbun. It is too early for school kids to comprehend fully how the grown-ups are engaging with dirty information war. Many teachers are siding with the leftists. Very messy situation it is.

  • Guest

    Such a stupid excuse! “To prevent students from leaning towards to one side.” Pu hahaha.

  • Toolonggone

    “If we allowed the exhibition by one specific group, it would mean that we are agreeing with one opinion while everyone has a right to form their own views,”

    Wonder if that logic will be applied to the groups that take an entirely opposite position.