/

China awaits Abe’s stance on 70th anniverary of WWII

Kyodo

China has warned it will keep a beady eye on the Abe administration’s words and deeds concerning historical issues next year, which will mark the 70th anniversary of the end of World War II.

During a meeting in Beijing, Yu Zhengsheng, the No. 4 ranking member of China’s Communist Party, told former chief Cabinet Secretary Yohei Kono, once a senior member of the governing Liberal Democratic Party, that any improvement in bilateral ties hinges largely on the actions of Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s government, a Kono aide said.

“Next year is the 70th anniversary and there will be a series of events in China. Chinese people are closely watching what kind of attitude Japan will take on historical issues,” Yu was quoted as telling Kono, who in 1993 issued the landmark state apology acknowledging that females euphemistically called “comfort women” were rounded up to serve as unwilling sex slaves in wartime brothels run by the Imperial Japanese military.

The meeting between Kono and Yu, who sits at China’s apex of power as one of the seven members of the Politburo Standing Committee of the Chinese Communist Party, was held at Beijing’s Great Hall of the People at a time when bilateral friction has eased, albeit marginally, after escalating alarmingly since 2012 over the Senkaku Islands dispute and divergent interpretations of history.

Despite being in office since December 2012, Abe held his first formal face-to-face talks with Chinese President Xi Jinping only about a month ago on the sidelines of an Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in Beijing. But the countries’ at times polar opposite views of wartime history, particularly the Imperial Japanese military’s ferocious invasion of and vicious colonial rule over wide swaths of Asia in the last century, including parts of China, remain a major obstacle to improving ties between Asia’s top two economies.

Beijing will be keeping an especially close watch on Abe, who scored a landslide victory in last Sunday’s general election, when he releases a statement next summer to commemorate the 70th anniversary of the end of the war.

In line with Xi’s first address at the Nanjing Massacre museum on Dec. 13 — the eve of the Lower House election — to mark the 77th anniversary of the Japanese atrocity, Yu was quoted by an aide as telling Kono, “What we have been criticizing is Japan’s militarists, not the people of Japan.”

Yu, who chairs the Communist Party’s top political advisory body, told Kono that Beijing has exercised a consistent policy of trying to build closer ties with Tokyo and that Xi’s address epitomized China’s stance on history, the aide said.

At the massacre memorial ceremony, which inaugurated the anniversary as a national day of remembrance for the first time, Xi said: “We should not bear hatred against an entire nation just because a small minority of militarists launched aggressive wars. The responsibility for war crimes lies with a few militarists, but not the people.

“Forgetting history is a betrayal and denying a crime is to repeat it,” Xi added.

Kono, 77, also served as foreign minister and held other key posts during a long career as a Lower House member before retiring from politics in 2009. He was one of the most dovish lawmakers in the LDP, which has lurched to the right under Abe’s stewardship since 2012, and he headed an association promoting trade and friendship between the China and Japan.

At the outset of the meeting, which was open to the press and arranged at the invitation of the Chinese Institute of Foreign Affairs, a government-affiliated entity, Yu praised Kono for issuing his famous 1993 apology as then-chief Cabinet secretary over the comfort women, saying that his statement, along with a 1995 document penned by then-Prime Minister Tomiichi Murayama, “left Chinese people (with) a deep impression.”

The Kono Statement, issued some 48 years after the end of the war, offered Japan’s first formal acknowledgement of the Imperial military’s involvement in setting up a network of brothels and its coercion of females to provide sex to Japanese troops throughout Asia before and during World War II. It also extended the Japanese government’s “sincere apologies” to the women forced to work in such “comfort stations,” as they are known in Japan, and expressed determination to learn from history so as not to repeat similar atrocities.

Earlier this year, a review conducted by Abe’s government of the process by which the Kono statement was created, which was supposed to be kept secret by both sides, was seen by critics both in Japan and overseas as an attempt to undermine the statement, if not a partial bid to rewrite history.

China and South Korea, which both suffered under Japan’s brutal colonial rule, have been at odds with Abe’s government, which they view as lacking repentance for wartime atrocities committed by Japanese troops.

  • blahblahandblah

    The Japanese people don’t understand why Chinese and Koreans in particular hate their government so much. It is easy for the Japanese government to deflect this as nationalistic propaganda but the truth is the Japanese government doesn’t want to admit their past errors; no government does.

    Atrocities were committed during the second world war (enforcement of women into sexual slavery, chemical weapons testing on people in Manchuria, the lowly act of falsely trying to save a “kidnapped” troop so as to start an invasion, …) and the Japanese government does not educate its people about. Why would it? What’s the benefit when no one in the west cares?

    Instead it is easier to paint oneself as a victim of a nuclear atrocity and a righteous nation seeking to liberate Asian from western imperialism than to speak the truth.

    It is time for the Japanese people to make their government make amends, one cannot his from the truth.

    Before people accuse me of being a propaganda troll, it might be worth reading a bit of history, a wiki of say “Nanjing massacre”, ” unit 731″, “Mukden incident” before trolling me.

    I don’t wish to divide.
    It’s just that the truth hurts.
    For both parties.
    A lot.

    The healing process cannot start unless both parties wholeheartedly look at the matter.

  • KoreanBuddha

    Japan is brainwashed island people. They hide the truth, when truth comes out. They find ways to lie about it. That is true Japan.

  • Ahojanen

    The Japanese government has already made official apologies several times and at crucial moments while Chinese and South Korean counterparts have politicised the history, making reconciliation efforts much harder to attain. They are more likely to link irrelevantly the wartime history to other conflicting yet “non-historical” issues.

    Both sides should at least agree to disagree, and recognise different historical perspectives. It is not at all a sign of weakness but maturity.

    • tiger

      maybe when the japanese people also get slaughtered by the millions, you can come back to the ‘agree to disagree’ bit.

    • blahblahandblah

      A word of advice.

      Japan is geographically in Asia.
      It is situated next to countries who believe it has not fully atoned for its crimes.
      The former cannot change.
      The later can.

      The US is on the other side of the world.
      It is a different country.
      Everyone cares more about themselves than they do other people.
      It will cut you lose the moment it is not longer in its interest to help you.

      There will be a day when Japan cannot but seek to reconcile with its neighbours.
      It is probably better to do so earlier rather than later.
      It is probably better to mean it than to put out half hearted statements and then to subsequently watering it down.

      Good luck trying to “agreeing to disagree”

  • ostkrieg

    Well, if you are at the head of an organization like the Chinese Communist Party that has presided over the killing of 30-50 million of its own citizens, and is siphoning off billions in cash to foreign accounts while talking of “socialism,” it is a good strategy to keep reminding your citizens that your neighbor (Japan) is really, really evil.

    • Guest

      Yep. Good perspective here:

      Hatch_bloody memories_P&C online_6.14.pdf

  • vjie

    Has Japan truly apologised for its ww2 crimes, when Abe and other politicians continue to rescind earlier admissions of wrong doing or assert that no evidence exist for crimes like sex slaves or the Nanking massacre? Steep in the shame culture, Japan finds it difficult to admit failure, defeat or having committed crimes.

    Face (not to be confused with honour) is very important to the Japanese. Japanese soldiers were directed to commit suicide rather than surrender to the enemy. Indeed, Hirohito’s surrender message on the radio to the nation on August 15 1945 carefully avoided mentioning the word “surrender”. Even today some Japanese who run foul of the law would rather commit suicide than face the court or the public.

    On a visit to a prestigious Japanese university, we were invited to an
    expensive dinner. Our host, a senior professor probably in his late 60’s, went to great lengths to extol the friendly ties between Japan and Asian countries, and at the end of that monologue, blurted out: “O, many years ago, Japan did many bad things”! And he didn’t elaborate; he just could not bear to bring himself to admit Japan’s criminal past.

    This seems to be quite typical behaviour. A Japanese social scientist attached to one of the Singapore universities was
    asked on TV what he thought of Japan’s WW2 involvement. His prompt response: “O, we were never interested in history – our interest was in the basketball!” And that was not the first time that I heard of basketball dominating the school curriculum in Japan.

    There are good reasons why Japan continues to deny its war crimes and responsibilities: Japan wants to justify its proposed abolishment of its peace constitution, justify its remilitarization, and hopes to become a member of the UN Security Council.

    Xi Jinping condemns the present Japanese leadership but maintains that the Japanese people is peace loving; his message to promote friendly relationship between the Chinese and the Japanese people is commendable.

    Japan cannot hope to command the respect of China, Korea and Asian countries until and unless it comes clean on its war time past. Japanese donations, soft loans, student grants, and dinners (!) etc are no substitute for a real apology.

    I am sorry for the remaining victims of the Nanking massacre, the sex slaves (especially from Korea, China and the Philippines), and other victims in Asia: they will NEVER get their apologies in their life time. I only hope that they would seek consolation in the belief that apologies would eventually come, with a more enlightened leadership. Japan cannot forever hide behind the coattails of US, which wants to see tension in Asia and is what is preventing a final settlement. vjie, singapore

    • blahblahandblah

      Re the “comfort women” better known as sex slaves: I believe it is Japanese government policy to just “wait it out”, as in, to wait for them all remaining survivors now in their old age to die. Hopefully the pain will be less and that the world will quietly forget?

      No nation can claim to be civilised to let such a thing happen.

      Japanese ruling class cannot admit error and Japanese people defend them believing they are “patriots” when in fact it is just ignorance of the facts because the ruling class wants it that way.

  • Toolonggone

    I’m not sure it’s worth awaiting for them.